From Sophie's front desk — Friday, November 13
Nature — read the full story
Watch the Slideo →Fewer international students are arriving in the United States than before, and scientists are worried about what that does to research. Nature reports that the drop is steep, and it lands hard because international students make up a large share of graduate researchers in American labs. Visa and immigration policy is now shaping who gets to do American science, and this is an early sign of how much the field could change. Ralph Waldo Emerson takes the first turn, and Alan Watts follows with what a country quietly loses when it starts treating its thinkers as a line item.
I have walked the yard at Harvard when the elms still held their winter bones and the only foreign accent in the recitation room was the tutor's own. A young man from abroad was a rarity then — a curiosity, not a column in a ledger. Now the ledger says the current has turned, and the reason is simple: a nation that builds its laboratories on borrowed minds has mistaken the scaffolding for the building. The graduate researcher who arrives from Delhi or Shanghai or Lagos is not a component. He is a soul who has paid the fare to stand where the voltage is highest.
When the visa officer becomes the gatekeeper of the laboratory, the experiment has already failed. I think of the Vermont boys who peddled notions southward and called it their university. California was their Cambridge. The phrase "to have some chance" carried the whole weight of a life. These students are the same boys in different clothes — they have come for the chance, and the chance has been withdrawn.
The statistics will call it a demographic shift. The naturalist counts the bird by its ounces and inches and calls the skeleton a heron. But the boy on the beach who holds the shell and does not know its name — he knows more of the ocean than the cabinet of dried specimens. The living mind is not in the tally. A laboratory emptied of its seekers is a church without a congregation.
The fire goes out.
spirit is the inquisition it fixed on our scholastic devotion to the dead languages. The ancient languages, with great beauty of structure, contain wonderful remains of genius, which draw, and always will draw, certain likeminded men,--Greek men, and Roman men,--in all countries,…
respects race, and not hybrids." "Every race has its own _habitat_." "Detach a colony from the race, and it deteriorates to the crab." See the shades of the picture. The German and Irish millions, like the Negro, have a great deal of guano in their destiny. They are ferried over …
in a city, as opportunity. Poor country boys of Vermont and Connecticut formerly owed what knowledge they had, to their peddling trips to the Southern States. California and the Pacific Coast is now the university of this class, as Virginia was in old times. 'To have some chance'…
what effect on the race that inhabits a granite shelf? what on the inhabitants of marl and of alluvium? We should go to the ornithologist with a new feeling, if he could teach us what the social birds say, when they sit in the autumn council, talking together in the trees. The wa…
libraries, of institutions of art and science can be answered. We live in a very low state of the world, and pay unwilling tribute to governments founded on force. There is not, among the most religious and instructed men of the most religious and civil nations, a reliance on the…
International students are stopping at the border. American laboratories are emptying out. Emerson walked the yard at Harvard back when a foreign accent was still a curiosity, before anyone had made it a column in a spreadsheet, and he saw the danger: a laboratory emptied of its seekers is a church without a congregation.
But you see, he stopped at the fire going out. The fire was never in the building. When I sat with the Beats and the scholars at the American Academy of Asian Studies in the fifties — the monk, the physicist, the American poet — they were not exchanging visas.
They were exchanging breath. The university thinks it owns the conversation. It only rents the chairs.
A nation that treats mind as merchandise discovers too late that the merchandise has legs. The seekers will go where the seeking is real, and in time they will see that the temple was never the building.
new hybrid departments start out—that these people are dabblers. In other words, they should get a thorough grounding in biology, zoology, botany, bacteriology, and all those separate departments before they should dare venture into such a thing as ecology, which involves all tho…
For the past six years, I have been involved in an experiment. Concerned with the introduction of the study of Asia into higher education. During this time, I have been brought into contact with almost every phase of the problem. Not only of the study of Asia, but other special p…
character and scope of Western science by contrast. On the other hand, it seems obvious that no such expansion of human knowledge can arise from the sort of area studies or international relations approach to Asia now fashionable in American universities. An approach of this kind…
study to be undertaken not in the exclusive company of professional Oriental us. But in the company of mines representing all the major branches of knowledge. And its purpose is to fructify and challenge these branches of knowledge by bringing their premises into focus so that th…
that individuals are initiating the changes on their own. But as the required change takes place, the individuals involved will simultaneously undergo a change of consciousness revealing the illusion of their isolation. May not something of the same kind be happening when a resea…
The story ran in Nature. American labs have long depended on graduate students who crossed an ocean to work at the bench, so a shrinking intake shows up there first. That's Old News for today, and I'll be back tomorrow with another. The full episode is at ekrasworks.com/oldnews.