Old News

From Sophie's front desk — Wednesday, October 7

Texas carries out first US execution since Christa Pike's botched lethal injections

BBC News — read the full story

▶ direct mp3 link

Jamaal Howard died in Texas today while Christa Pike lay in a Tennessee hospital, her veins still clotting from an execution that failed to kill her. The state moved forward anyway—each procedure a bet that this time the chemistry will work, that the protocol holds. Franklin has something to say about the machinery of state killing, then Krishnamurti.

Benjamin Franklin
as imagined by Old News

I have watched the hangman's cart rattle over cobblestones enough times to know the sound it makes when the wheel binds — the state does not stop for a broken axle. You read of Tennessee's botched needle and Texas's next name on the warrant and call it a failure of protocol. I call it the protocol working as intended. The machinery of death does not pause to inspect its own gears; it only advances to the next appointment. In my final winter the gout seized my joints and the pleurisy took my breath, and I lay in that bed on Market Street watching the doctors confer — bleeding, blistering, opium — each remedy a small execution in its own right.

The body resists. The state does not. When the Paxton Boys marched on Philadelphia demanding the blood of Conestoga Indians already in protective custody, the Assembly debated jurisdiction while the mob sharpened knives. Process is the shelter power builds around its appetites. A coach breaks down on the Boston Post Road and the passenger waits in the rain.

A ship founders on the Newfoundland banks and the owner collects the insurance. But the warrant? The warrant travels in a carriage that never loses a wheel. The needle finds the vein or it does not; the clerk records the time of death either way. The system has no memory for its own mistakes — only for the names it has crossed off.

The rope, the current, the chemical — same ledger, different ink.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. correspondence:Pennsylvania Assembly: Reply to the Governor, 20 January 1764
    everything in revenge.” Reports of a proposed march on the city increased, and after the events at Conestoga and Lancaster were known in Philadelphia it became clear that the major objective of such a march would be the killing of the Indians on Province Island. It seemed desirab…
  2. correspondence:A Defense of Conduct, 15 February 1738
    only an unfortunate accident, but the grand jury, receiving evidence that Jones had thrown the spirits willfully, indicted him, Remington, and Tackerbury for murder. Andrew Bradford used the opportunity to attack the Masons: on August 4 the American Weekly Mercury printed an unfr…
  3. civic:Jonathan Williams, Jr., to the American Commissioners, 10 June 1777
    Gentlemen Nantes June 10 1777. The Intention of this is to ask your Interest in favour of a poor american Sailor who I am afraid will otherwise be executed for Murder. The Fact as it was related to me by his Captain is this. The deceased and the prisoner were going asshore in the…
  4. civic:The American Commissioners to Lord North, 12 December 1777
    these public acts. Col. Parker, a gentleman of rank, was thrown into a common gaol in Boston, covered over with wounds, where he perished unpitied, for want of the common comforts which his situation and humanity required. Colonel Ethan Allan was dragged, in chains, from Canada t…
  5. correspondence:Benjamin Franklin to Joseph Galloway, 14 May 1768
    are killed and fifteen or sixteen wounded, and some circumstances have attended this military execution, such as its being done by the Scotch regiment, the pursuing a lad and killing him at his father’s house &c. &c. that exasperate people exceedingly, and more mischief seems bre…
J. Krishnamurti
as imagined by Old News

Benjamin Franklin heard the cart's wheel bind on the cobblestones and called it a ledger — same ledger, different ink. But last week in Tennessee, Christa Pike did not die cleanly. The needle failed. The chemicals pooled in tissue instead of vein. Her lungs filled with fluid.

Blood clots formed. She lay in a hospital bed, unconscious, while the warrant waited. Texas watched the reports and proceeded anyway with Jamaal Howard. Sir, I have walked the same road in Ojai each morning for forty years and watched the mind justify what the hand does. The clerk records the time of death.

The doctor pronounces. The witness signs. But the ledger Franklin names is not kept by the clerk — it is kept in the body of the man who straps down the prisoner, in the nurse who cannot find the vein, in the official who reads the protocol and does not ask what protocol serves. We have killed for religion, for country, for peace, for justice — each time believing this killing is different, this one is necessary. The rope, the current, the chemical: the instrument changes, the certainty does not.

The sorrow is not in the ledger. It is in the quiet room afterward where no one speaks.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. krishnamurti:ROME 4TH PUBLIC DISCUSSION 10TH APRIL 1966
    One has to do something about the problem of starvation in Asia. To feed all the people, there must be no nationalities, no sovereign States, no Italian government, Indian government, American government. Science has enough creative knowledge to give food, shelter and clothing t…
  2. krishnamurti:THE FIRST AND LAST FREEDOM QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS QUESTION 1 'ON THE PRESENT CRISIS'
    Krishnamurti: Obviously the present crisis throughout the world is exceptional, without precedent. There have been crises of varying types at different periods throughout history, social, national, political. Crises come and go; economic recessions, depressions, come, get modif…
  3. krishnamurti:SANTIAGO 3RD PUBLIC TALK 8TH SEPTEMBER, 1935
    SANTIAGO 3RD PUBLIC TALK 8TH SEPTEMBER, 1935Question: What have you to say about the treatment of criminals? Krishnamurti: Now it all depends upon whom you call a criminal. A pathological person is not a criminal, and it is folly to put him in a prison. He needs medical attenti…
  4. krishnamurti:KRISHNAMURTI TO HIMSELF OJAI CALIFORNIA WEDNESDAY 16TH MARCH, 1983 (CONTINUING THE DIALOGUE OF 15TH MARCH 1983)
    KRISHNAMURTI TO HIMSELF OJAI CALIFORNIA WEDNESDAY 16TH MARCH, 1983 (CONTINUING THE DIALOGUE OF 15TH MARCH 1983)`MAN HAS KILLED man in different states of mind. He has killed him for religious reasons, he has killed him for patriotic reasons, for peace, killed him through organiz…
  5. krishnamurti:OJAI 5TH PUBLIC TALK 1945
    When acquisitiveness in every form is encouraged, when nationalism and separate sovereign states exist, when religion separates, when there is intolerance and ignorance then killing your fellowman is inevitable. War is the result of our every day life. Passion, ill will and oppr…

BBC carried the piece. Howard's execution went forward in Texas the same week Tennessee's botched lethal injection left Christa Pike hospitalized—a parallel that might say something about how institutions absorb their own failures and keep moving. That's Old News for today.