Old News

From Sophie's front desk — Friday, October 16

Brazil sees record fall in Amazon deforestation as key election looms

BBC News — read the full story

▶ direct mp3 link

The Amazon's deforestation has collapsed—forty-two percent in a single year, the lowest on record. BBC reports that Brazil's rainforest, hammered open under Bolsonaro, is closing back up under Lula's stricter protections, and the timing arrives just as the election runoff heats. Emerson has the first word on what a nation owes to the ground it stands on, then Thoreau.

Ralph Waldo Emerson
as imagined by Old News

The axe rings differently in Brazil this season. Forty-two percent less forest fallen — the lowest mark the record keeps. The machine that counts the trees does not know why the hand paused, but the forest knows. It has known this pause before. I walked the Concord woods when the sheep pastures were eating the hills. We cleared three-quarters of New England for firewood and charcoal, for the forge and the hearth, and called it improvement. The pine that stood two hundred years fell in an afternoon. The squirrel had no vote. The brook had no lobby.

We were the Bolsonaro of our own woods, and the land bore it — bore us — because the constitution of nature is stronger than the parliament of men. Now the wind shifts. A government chooses the standing tree over the falling one. The carbon buffer breathes. The election looms and the forest becomes a platform. But do not mistake the policy for the power. The law that protects the canopy is written in older ink than any constitution. The leaf does not read the decree; it drinks the light. I am an old man now.

My memory fails me in the study — names slip, dates blur, the sentence I meant to write dissolves before the pen finds it. Yet I remember the phonograph in the newspaper: a cylinder that catches a voice and gives it back. The forest has no cylinder. It keeps its own counsel. The axe may return. The election may turn. But the tree that stands today has already won the only argument that matters. The forest does not vote. It outlives the voter.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. emerson:poems
    Water and the Lake of Loons. Northward the length of Follansbee we rowed, Under low mountains, whose unbroken ridge Ponderous with beechen forest sloped the shore. A pause and council: then, where near the head Due east a bay makes inward to the land Between two rocky arms, we cl…
  2. emerson:conduct_of_life
    other,--might easily believe that he and his country have seen their best days, and he hardens himself the best he can against the coming ruin. But, after this has been foretold with equal confidence fifty times, and government six per cents have not declined a quarter of a mill,…
  3. emerson:conduct_of_life
    was a finality, to-day is yielding to a larger generalization? With such volatile elements to work in, 'tis no wonder if our estimates are loose and floating. We must work and affirm, but we have no guess of the value of what we say or do. The cloud is now as big as your hand, an…
  4. emerson:essays_first
    the dangers and glories of blue water."] [Footnote 4: Pole-star. Polaris is now the nearest conspicuous star to the north pole of the celestial equator. Owing to the motion of the pole of the celestial equator around that of the ecliptic, this star will in course of time recede f…
  5. emerson:essays_second
    in winter days. Unluckily, in the exertions necessary to remove these inconveniences, the main attention has been diverted to this object; the old aims have been lost sight of, and to remove friction has come to be the end. That is the ridicule of rich men, and Boston, London, Vi…
Henry David Thoreau
as imagined by Old News

Emerson says the forest outlives the voter. He is wrong about the part that matters. The forest does not merely outlive — it is held hostage while the votes are counted. Forty-two percent less fallen this season, the machine reports, and Lula's hand holds the axe differently than Bolsonaro's did. But the axe has not been laid down. It has only paused.

I know the sound of an axe in winter woods. I have measured the stumps. The engineer who disregards the river's old high-water mark finds his rails underwater come freshet — I saw it on the Concord, the water rising nine inches from the ties. The forest keeps its own counsel, yes, but the counsel is written in rings you cannot read from any telegraph. The sand foliage at the bank where the frost comes out — those leaf-forms the melting water makes — they are the forest's ledger, not the politician's proclamation. One night in jail taught me that a law which requires me to be an agent of injustice is a law I break.

The forest breaks no law. It simply falls, or stands, at the pleasure of men who call it policy. The pickerel-weed in my herbarium knows the water's level better than any senator. The election turns. The axe returns. The tree that stands today has not won — it has only been granted a reprieve by men who will forget it by morning.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. thoreau:walking
    the rivers longer, the forests bigger, the plains broader.” This statement will do at least to set against Buffon’s account of this part of the world and its productions. Linnæus said long ago, “Nescio quæ facies læta, glabra plantis Americanis” (I know not what there is of joyou…
  2. thoreau:walden
    mass reaches the drain at the foot of the bank it spreads out flatter into _strands_, the separate streams losing their semi-cylindrical form and gradually becoming more flat and broad, running together as they are more moist, till they form an almost flat _sand_, still variously…
  3. thoreau:walden
    a new leaf at last? This phenomenon is more exhilarating to me than the luxuriance and fertility of vineyards. True, it is somewhat excrementitious in its character, and there is no end to the heaps of liver lights and bowels, as if the globe were turned wrong side outward; but t…
  4. thoreau:a_week
    engineer disregarded this statement, and I learn that there has since been a freshet which rose within nine inches of the rails at Biscuit Brook, and such a freshet as that of 1785 would have covered the railroad two feet deep. The revolutions of nature tell as fine tales, and ma…
  5. thoreau:walden
    the race of King Saturn.” We are wont to forget that the sun looks on our cultivated fields and on the prairies and forests without distinction. They all reflect and absorb his rays alike, and the former make but a small part of the glorious picture which he beholds in his daily …

The story ran in BBC News. A 42 percent drop in Amazon deforestation — the lowest on record — arrives just as Brazil heads to a runoff election, a reversal of the acceleration under Bolsonaro. That's Old News for today.