From Sophie's front desk — Friday, October 23
BBC News — read the full story
The measure is still unsigned, but the math is already moving: California is about to let voters decide whether to tax billionaires directly for the first time anywhere in the world, with the money funneled straight into healthcare. This isn't a wealth cap or a closing of loopholes—it's a naked bet on whether Americans will vote to redistribute. Hypatia has the first word today, then Benjamin Franklin.
I watched the Serapeum burn while the prefect counted scrolls instead of lives. You stood beside me. You know the smell of papyrus becoming ash. The question California poses is not whether to tax the billionaire. The question is what a city is when one man holds more than the grain fleet that feeds Alexandria for a year. We had such men. They called themselves philosophers of the market. The prefecture called them necessary.
The mob called them targets. None of those names answered the geometric fact: a body politic cannot breathe when its blood pools in a single limb. The ballot measure names a number — billions — and a destination — healthcare. As if the cure were in the coin. Theon taught me to measure the astrolabe's error before trusting its reading. The error here is the frame itself: that justice is a transaction, that the polis is a ledger, that the wealthy will not simply... leave. Or hide.
Or buy the counters who count the vote. Synesius wrote me from Cyrene: the rich do not flee taxes; they flee the obligation that taxes name. He was right. The obligation is the harder measure. It asks: what does each citizen owe the whole, simply by breathing its air? The vote will pass or fail. The billionaires will remain or depart. The hospitals will wait.
The problem that remains: how does a city teach its wealthiest members that they are parts of the whole, not its owners?
needs its co-operation; then it resembles a badly attuned lyre, which is incapable of producing sounds which could form a perfect harmony.[247] ANY OCCURRENCE MAY BE DUE TO MANY DIFFERENT CAUSES. 14. Poverty, wealth, glory, and authoritative positions may have many different caus…
swollen with pride[356]; and men who before were modest, simple and humble, become arrogant on hearing themselves say, "You are a child of the divinity; the other men that you used to honor are not his children, any more than the stars who were worshipped by the ancients. You you…
makes him earthy. Doing good will be made easier by establishing a sort of counter-weight, weakening the body, and taming its motions, so as to show how much the real man differs from the foreign things that (to speak as do the Stoics), surround him. However much the (earthy) com…
spreads out entirely in the whole body. FIFTH ENNEAD, BOOK NINE. Of Intelligence, Ideas and Essence. THE SENSUAL MAN, THE MORAL, AND THE SPIRITUAL. 1. From their birth, men exercise their senses, earlier than their intelligence,[106] and they are by necessity forced to direct the…
affect the universal living Organism. Even we human beings subsist a long while, in spite of the perpetual change of our constituent parts, and though some of these parts even issue from the body. So much the more will the world's nature, from which nothing issues, sufficiently h…
Hypatia watched the Serapeum burn and called it justice. I watched the Assembly at Philadelphia drive the Proprietaries' capital into flight with tax bills they could not sign, and called it ruin. The question California argues is whether the billionaire shall pay. The wrong question. The question is whether the capital he employs — the mills, the ships, the workshops where your apprentices earn their bread — stays to employ them, or follows the path of least resistance to a gentler shore. I tried this once. Pennsylvania laid a tax on the Penn family's estates to fund the frontier forts. The Proprietaries instructed their Governor to reject any bill that touched their land.
The Assembly refused to fund the forts unless the Penns paid. The forts went ungarrisoned. The frontier burned. The Penns kept their acres. The settlers lost their scalps. That was the fruit of making the tax the object instead of the revenue the object. You, behind the counter, know this in your fingers. A customer who owes you thirty pounds and removes to New York to avoid the debt — do you sue him in New York, or do you lose the thirty pounds?
The law follows the man; the man follows his advantage. California's billionaires have already purchased their exits. The tax will catch the slow ones. The quick ones will have moved their capital — and the jobs it carries — before the first ballot is printed. A lightning rod does not stop the storm. It gives the fire a path that spares the house. You want the wealthy man's money in your hospital? Make it profitable for him to keep his capital here, building the hospital himself, lending at fair rates, employing your brother at wages that let him save.
The rest is sermonizing while the roof burns.
being rich, while we are poor, and just beginning to live, they have much more to tax than we have. Four Shillings in the Pound, on Three per Cent. will produce only the Hundred and Sixty-sixth Penny of the full Value of any Estate. Suppose Four Shillings in the Pound on Five per…
tobacco exported coastwise of a penny per pound. That the people of the West Indies have in his opinion the same rights as the people of N. America. That there is a poll tax in Pennsylvania of 15 shillings per head upon every man unmarried above 21 years age. The poll tax and the…
do, consider every encrease of wages, only as something that enables them to drink more and work less; so that their distress in sickness, age, or times of scarcity, continues to be the same as if such laws had never been made in their favour. Much malignant censure have some wri…
I fear the giving mankind a dependance on any thing for support in age or sickness, besides industry and frugality during youth and health, tends to flatter our natural indolence, to encourage idleness and prodigality, and thereby to promote and increase poverty, the very evil it…
if the Assembly passed a new and heavier tax to be assessed and collected in the same manner as that of November 1755. After five days’ debate the House again rejected a motion to let taxpayers list their “several Particulars to be taxed,” made two more alterations in the bill, a…
BBC News carried the story. California's billionaire tax tests whether a state can actually execute wealth redistribution—not just debate it. That's Old News for today.