From Sophie's front desk — Sunday, November 15
Reuters — read the full story
Watch the Slideo →Is a fine of about €805 million a real cost to a company that quietly reached into people's phone galleries, or just the price of doing business? Italy's privacy regulator, the Garante, reached that figure after finding that Meta's Facebook Android app accessed photos, videos and metadata from roughly 20 million Italian users through a gallery-suggestion feature that was switched on by default. Meta says it will appeal, and the probe did not cover whether those gallery files were used to train AI models. Epictetus takes the first call on what consent means when the setting was never really chosen, and then Alan Watts picks up why a default ever passed for agreement.
A company — let us call it what it is, a merchant of attention — reached into twenty million pockets and took the photographs. Not the objects; the originals remain on the device. But the choice whether to show them? That was taken. By default. As though your assent were a public road, and the toll already paid. The fine they levy — eight hundred million of their coins — amounts to less than half a hundredth of what the merchant gathers in a year.
A cost of doing business. They will appeal, of course. They treat the penalty as a reckoning; it is only a ledger entry. In Nicopolis, when a student came to the school, we did not begin with his luggage. We began with his judgements. What he carried in his pack was his own affair. But if he let another man decide what was worth keeping and what was worth showing — then he had already left the school before he arrived.
The investigation did not ask whether the merchant fed these images to the artifice they call intelligence, the calculation that learns without a mind. That question is reserved for later. As though the theft of the choice were separate from the use of the spoils. You handed over the gallery because the setting said on. You did not turn it off. You took the default for a kindness, though it was a trap. What did you think was yours to guard, that you let a default setting guard for you?
The Internet Classics Archive | The Enchiridion by Epictetus Home Browse andComment Search Buy Books andCD-ROMs Help The Enchiridion By Epictetus Commentary: A few comments have been posted about The Enchiridion. Download: A 40k text-only version is available for download. The En…
and if we observe this rule in every act, we shall undertake this act with more security. XXXIX. The measure of possession (property) is to every man the body, as the foot is of the shoe. If then you stand on this rule (the demands of the body), you will maintain the measure; but…
and if we observe this rule in every act, we shall undertake this act with more security. XXXIX. The measure of possession (property) is to every man the body, as the foot is of the shoe. If then you stand on this rule (the demands of the body), you will maintain the measure; but…
the reason of this? The reason is that we have never read for this purpose, we have never written for this purpose, so that we may in our actions use in a way conformable to nature the appearances presented to us; but we terminate in this, in learning what is said, and in being a…
the reason of this? The reason is that we have never read for this purpose, we have never written for this purpose, so that we may in our actions use in a way conformable to nature the appearances presented to us; but we terminate in this, in learning what is said, and in being a…
Epictetus has the right of it — the default is the modern devil. No consent asked, no consent given. The signal just arrived. But there it is: the medium decides what you receive before you've chosen a thing. And the photographs — twenty million pockets. I think of the ferryboat at Sausalito, the Vallejo, where I used to write. But now the film is inside the machine, and the machine has habits you never agreed to. A gallery-suggestion feature, they call it.
As if your memories were a menu. You see, the Confucians wanted the rectification of names — call a thing what it is, and order follows. The Taoists knew better. Call a trap a "feature," call surveillance "suggestion," and the trap springs anyway. Meta will appeal, of course. They always appeal. The fine is four-tenths of one percent of revenue — the cost of doing business, as they say. But here's the quiet part: nobody meant harm.
The engineers built a convenience. The lawyers wrote a default. The users clicked "okay" because who reads the terms? And twenty million photo albums drifted into someone else's index. Not theft, exactly. Just... the way the current flows when you're not watching. I suppose the question isn't whether the default is a trap.
It's whether we'll remember how to turn the knob ourselves.
are all at this moment doing something illegal. I don’t know what it is but it’s always there and somebody can find it out and invoke it if they wish to make trouble for us. I’m quite sure that my entire situation is illegal. And that’s a so for everybody. And this is the result …
WHATS -EAO? A ££ a WN WA. EF FS Author of What Is Zen? WHAT IS TAO? WHAT IS TAO? ALAN WATTS ot Woe oa ‘e iy Faas’ TT NEW WORLD LIBRARY ORNIA ot Woe, TEN “aw New World Library 14 Pamaron Way Novato, California 94949 Copyright © 2000 by Mark Watts The poems on pages v, 22, and 52, …
yours, Alan Watts SOCIETY FOR COMPARATIVE PHILOSOPHY | SAUSALITO, CALIFORNIA | APRIL 29, 1966 Mr. Pearce Young | Chairman, Assembly Criminal Procedures Committee | Sacramento, California Dear Mr. Young: Your committee is very much to be commended for resisting the pressures for “…
what they’re doing to have the paranoid reaction altogether reinforced. And so naturally, the illegality, the reasons that the government puts forward for making it illegal are of the nature of a self-fulfilling prophecy. By making it illegal, they make it harmful. Then they can …
research tools. Just as you magnify your senses with a telephone which enables you to hear for thousands of miles with television, which enables you to see for thousands of miles over the telescope, over the microscope, which enables you to see things totally invisible to the nak…
Reuters carried the story of Italy's €805 million fine against Meta, over Facebook's Android app reaching into the photos of roughly twenty million Italian users by default. The regulator's real demand is simple: ask first, and make the default honest. That's Old News for today. The full episode is at ekrasworks.com/oldnews.