From Sophie's front desk — Friday, October 23
Al Jazeera — read the full story
AI's eating jobs twice as fast in Britain. Double the rate of the States and Germany. The UK's the outlier. Al Jazeera's looking at why—and whether the safety nets hold when automation hits this hard. Thoreau has the first word, then Watts.
I read the dispatch over cold coffee. Britain shedding its clerks and calculators at twice the American pace — the papers call it intelligence, artificial, as though the adjective purified the verb. I have seen this before. The locomotive's scream split my woods in '44; the mill owners said it brought prosperity, and it brought prosperity to the mill owners. The operatives in Lowell learned that a loom tends itself better than a family tends its supper. At Harvard we read Smith and Say; we were taught that labor finds its level.
What we were not taught: that the level is set by men who never touch the work. A clerk in London spends thirty years mastering a ledger; the new engine masters it in an afternoon. The economy calls this efficiency. I call it the same account the railroad kept: the track laid across the common, the timetable replacing the season, and the men who built the road told to walk beside it. Britain's peculiar severity? She industrialized first, so she forgets first.
The factory floor emptied into the counting house; now the counting house empties into the server room. Each migration sold as liberation. The chickadee at my window does not calculate its winter stores by a ledger. It calculates by the cone crop and the wind. The cone crop does not lie. The wind does not restructure.
is a very crooked one, every moment. Beside being better off than they already, if my house had been burned or my crops had failed, I should have been nearly as well off as before. I am wont to think that men are not so much the keepers of herds as herds are the keepers of men, t…
in the orbit of the earth. The whistle of the locomotive penetrates my woods summer and winter, sounding like the scream of a hawk sailing over some farmer’s yard, informing me that many restless city merchants are arriving within the circle of the town, or adventurous country tr…
not. These mouldering elements are slowly preparing for another metamorphosis, to serve new masters, and what was the Indian’s will erelong be the white man’s sinew. We learned that Bedford was not so famous for hops as formerly, since the price is fluctuating, and poles are now …
significant fact, stated by entomologists, I find it in Kirby and Spence, that “some insects in their perfect state, though furnished with organs of feeding, make no use of them;” and they lay it down as “a general rule, that almost all insects in this state eat much less than in…
crisis? “A drab of state, a cloth-o’-silver slut, To have her train borne up, and her soul trail in the dirt.” Practically speaking, the opponents to a reform in Massachusetts are not a hundred thousand politicians at the South, but a hundred thousand merchants and farmers here, …
Henry Thoreau heard the locomotive scream in forty-four and called it invasion, but you see, the scream was always ours — we laid the tracks, we stoked the fire, and now we act surprised when the train arrives exactly on schedule.
The British are shedding their clerks at twice the American clip not because their machines are cleverer but because their bureaucracy was always more thorough, more perfectly rationalized, more ripe for the harvest; a system that runs on pure prickles eventually begs for the goo, and the goo has arrived in the form of algorithms that never tire, never unionize, never ask for a pension, never stare out the window at three in the afternoon wondering what it was all for, never wake at midnight with the particular terror that they have spent forty years adding columns of figures that no one will ever read.
We built a world where human value equals computational throughput, and now we clutch our pearls when the throughput outruns the human — but the real joke, the one the chickadee would laugh at if it had our sense of irony, is that we never actually liked the ledger, we only liked the feeling of being indispensable to it, so what happens to the feeling when the ledger keeps itself and we are left with nothing but the window and the wind?
submit is a ghastly era. Because human intelligence has a very serious limitation. That limitation is. That it is a scanning system, of conscious attention, which is linear. That is to say, it examines the world, in lines. Rather as you would pass the beam of a flashlight across …
have again got to bring up the right foot, the analytic perspective. After goo comes prickles, and after prickles comes goo. I think our danger at the present time is such that we are so heady, so delighted with the results of prickles, that we have to allow a little bit of goo b…
about this now, because of the rise of the computer. Do you know this this is terribly interesting that a new form of. Intelligence to see is come into the world which is in certain directions vastly superior to human intelligence. And people are beginning to worry like anything …
is not intelligent to trust what you have not analyzed. It looks, then, as if there is conflict, contradiction, and thus anxiety in the very nature of intelligence. As an efficient though slow and laborious means of conscious control, it builds up a body of information too comple…
men—so much so that in a not too distant future the human brain may be an obsolete mechanism for logical calculation. Already the human computer is widely displaced by mechanical and electrical computers of far greater speed and efficiency. If, then, man’s principal asset and val…
Al Jazeera carried this piece. Britain is automating its workforce at twice the pace of the United States and Germany — a disparity that suggests something particular about how different economies are absorbing artificial intelligence, not just that AI itself is neutral. That's Old News for today.