From Sophie's front desk — Sunday, October 4
NYT — read the full story
Boulder is suing Exxon and Suncor for climate damages—the case heads to the Supreme Court as the first real test of whether fossil fuel companies can be held financially liable for the harm they've caused. The New York Times reports on litigation that treats climate change not as an abstraction but as a quantifiable debt owed by specific corporations to a specific place. Seneca has the first word, then Hypatia.
Lucilius, a letter arrives from the provinces describing a city that has hauled two great merchants before the highest tribunal, demanding they answer for the smoke their trade has left in the common air. The merchants grew rich; the city counts its losses in burned forests and flooded fields. The judges will decide whether the law can reach so far backward — whether profit taken yesterday can be made to pay for ruin that arrives tomorrow. I think of the benefit I once sent to a man in Gaul, and how he turned it against me when the winds shifted. The benefit itself, I wrote, is incorporeal; only its subject-matter changes hands.
But here the subject-matter is the sky itself, and the merchants say they never signed a contract with the atmosphere. The law has actions for theft and actions for deposit, each proceeding on its own track. It has no action for the slow poisoning of a province. When Nero's guards stood at my door, I cut my veins in a warm bath and dictated to scribes until the water cooled. The order bore the seal of law.
The law that condemned me also protected the men who profited from my condemnation. We call it justice because it wears the toga. The city of Boulder — let us call it that — asks whether the merchant who sells the fire must answer for the ash. The merchants answer that they sold only the fire, and the ash belongs to the wind. Who owns the wind, Lucilius, and who pays when the wind carries the bill?
what the law may be among you Stoic philosophers in such a case. I suppose that you keep the action which I bring against another distinct from that which he Strings against me, and the two processes are not merged into one? For instance, if a man entrusts me with money, and afte…
others out of court, and put an end to them at once. II. It is a question whether a benefit can be taken away from one by force. Some say that it cannot, because it is not a thing, but an act. A gift is not the same as the act of giving, any more than a sailor is the same as the …
the cases which I have mentioned, each party is the owner of the same thing. How is this? It is because the one owns the thing, the other owns the use of the thing. We speak of the books of Cicero. Dorus, the bookseller, calls these same books his own; the one claims them because…
division of philosophy is made—into _Physics_, dealing with the universe and its laws, the problems of divine government and teleology; _Logic_, which trains the mind to discern true from false; and _Ethics_, which applies the knowledge thus gained and tested to practical life. T…
to reckon accurately the penalty for so varying a matter, we condemn it only to be hated, and place it upon the list of those crimes which we refer for judgment to the gods. VII. Many arguments occur to me which prove that this vice ought not to come under the action of the law. …
Seneca asked who owns the wind. I have watched the wind carry ash from the Serapeum's burning scrolls across the Bruchion quarter — the same wind that carries the Nile's scent to the Pharos. The merchants of fire in Boulder, Colorado — Exxon, Suncor — they sold the fire. The ash settles on mountains I will never see, on glaciers that feed rivers I will never name. The highest tribunal in that land now asks whether the sellers answer for what the wind carries. In Alexandria, my father Theon taught me to calculate the sun's return within a day's error. We measured the shadow on the gnomon at noon.
The calculation was necessary; the shadow was probable. The merchants knew the calculation — their own scribes computed the warming generations before they denied it. They sold the fire anyway. The ash is not probable. The ash is necessary. Synesius wrote to me from Cyrene describing drought that turned grain to dust. A woman in Boulder measures flood damage in coin.
A farmer in the Nile Delta measures it in failed harvest. The wind does not distinguish. The tribunal will decide whether law can reach across the distance between seller and ash. In the Mouseion we proved that a line drawn from the center to the circumference meets every radius at the same angle. The distance does not change the geometry. The fire was sold. The ash fell.
The wind is not the question — the question is whether the tribunal will measure the angle.
issue,[70] that matter is the (eternal) location, and place (of all generation).[71] MATTER AS LOCATION OF FORMS REMAINS IMPASSIBLE. When Plato, rightfully, calls matter "the location of forms," he is not thereby attributing any passion to matter; he only indicates that matters g…
of resistance corporeal nature[214]). Only of earth may hardness be predicated; indeed, gold, in liquid state, is dense; not because it is earth, but because it possesses density, and is solidified. It would therefore not be unreasonable that fire, apart by itself, could subsist …
affect the universal living Organism. Even we human beings subsist a long while, in spite of the perpetual change of our constituent parts, and though some of these parts even issue from the body. So much the more will the world's nature, from which nothing issues, sufficiently h…
not extend down to the earth.[47] No! For all of the rest (of this world) conforms to (universal) Reason, inasmuch as animals and plants participate in Reason, Life and Soul. (The Gnostic) will answer that if Providence do extend to this earth, it does not predominate therein. As…
eternally good. ANALYSIS OF THE EARTH'S PSYCHOLOGY. 27. If the earth communicate to plant-life the power of begetting and growing, it possesses this power within itself, and gives only a trace of it to the plants which derive from it all their fruitfulness, and as it were are the…
The story ran in the New York Times. Boulder is asking courts to make fossil fuel companies pay for climate damage—a test of whether the legal system can attach a price tag to what the atmosphere costs. That's Old News for today.