Old News

From Sophie's front desk — Monday, November 16

China and Russia confirm first-ever Trump-Xi-Putin summit in Shenzhen

Reuters — read the full story

Watch the Slideo →
The conversation on the page, with pullouts, context and sources as they speak
▶ direct mp3 link

Can three leaders who trust none of each other turn a photo opportunity into a binding bargain? Reuters reports that Beijing and Moscow have confirmed Xi, Trump and Putin will sit down together for the first time, in Shenzhen on Thursday. The Kremlin says a joint communiqué is already being drafted, even though China has refused nuclear-arms talks with Washington and Moscow. Hildegard of Bingen goes first on what a communiqué drafted before anyone sits down can promise, then Benjamin Franklin takes the arms question.

Hildegard of Bingen
as imagined by Old News

I wrote to Frederick once, with iron-gall ink on parchment, when he set up his antipope against the true seat. The green sap rises in the branch only when the root drinks from the living spring. If the root drinks poison, the crown withers though it wear gold. Three rulers meet in a southern city. They speak of an old alliance forged in fire, of a charter signed in smoke.

One carries the eagle, one the dragon, one the bear. They sit at a table where the agenda is already written in a communiqué negotiated before they arrive. Such tables are not new to me. The wall of the city is attacked, the plain plundered, and the tower-keeper guards only his tower. The dove does not nest in a fortress built on dried blood.

Viriditas does not flow from a communiqué. It flows from the wound that admits the light. When I wrote to Eugenius, I did not negotiate terms. I described what the burning light showed me: the Church as a woman in labor, the emperor as a man who forgot his anointing. Three men in a room.

What they sign matters little to me. I want to know whether any of them still feels the sap rise in his own fingers, or whether all three have become dry wood polished to look living.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. hildegard:751
    Everywhere distinct, and it says: I conquer in the east with the strongest Son of God: who went out from the Father, coming into the world for the redemption of men, and who again returned to the Father; with in the greatest distress dying on the cross and rising from the dead, a…
  2. hildegard:802
    Of God. How? Because the most profound and chief *sapientia* has been placed by the grace of God in the mouth of human rationality, so that man may exercise the office of magisterium in the name of God, through the strictness of justice and the mercy of the same Most High. Which,…
  3. hildegard:197
    You who are in the place of Christ, hear again: A certain king had a certain city in great honors, which he entrusted to three men of his people, so that they might have the care of it in custody. Indeed, he entrusted the first with the tower, the second with the plain of the cit…
  4. hildegard:168
    — he was stirred), under Frederick, the Roman emperor of dignity. He recalls his previous visions and does not keep silent about his preceding writings: Just as in my previous visions I had spoken before; and below: Because I had written all things from the beginning of my vision…
  5. hildegard:869
    With fortifications. A thousand shields hang from it, all the armor of the strong. This is such. Just as the incarnation of the Son of the highest ruler, namely the strongest lion coming from the virgin flower, the strongest instrument of new grace was placed, so the fortitude of…
Benjamin Franklin
as imagined by Old News

Hildegard of Bingen has it exactly: three men in a room, and the parchment already written before they sit down. I knew this trade. In Paris, Vergennes would have the treaty drafted in his cabinet while we commissioners were still being shown the gilt chairs.

A joint communiqué "already being negotiated" — why, that is the signal that the meeting is theater, the substance having departed weeks prior. As Postmaster, I saw how the news moved: the newspapers print what the ministry releases, the packet boat carries what the captain chooses, and the truth rides a slower horse — a private letter, a ciphered dispatch, a conversation in the yard of the London Coffee House. These three sovereigns will sign what their ministers agreed beforehand, and posterity will file the signing under history.

The sap does not rise in the branch when the root has been severed from the spring for months. What puzzles me is not the theater — I have written the script myself — but the speed. In my day, a treaty crossed the sea twice before a signature dried.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. civic:The American Peace Commissioners to Prince Bariatinskii, [2 July 1783]
    On Tuesday, July 1, at the weekly gathering of ministers at Versailles, Vergennes informed the American peace commissioners that the Anglo-French treaty had been settled, pending British approval, and the time had come for them to pay official visits to the Russian and Austrian m…
  2. correspondence:The Swedish-American Treaty of Amity and Commerce, with Translation, 3 April [i.e., 5 March] 1783
    based on the Franco-American Treaty of Amity and Commerce, with a few additions taken from the recently concluded Dutch-American treaty. Finding that the two proposals differed “in several points,” Creutz sought further instructions from his court, informing Gustavus III that he …
  3. correspondence:The Swedish-American Treaty of Amity and Commerce, with Translation, 3 April [i.e., 5 March] 1783
    accompanying dispatch from the president of the Chancellery, that the king’s concerns about potential British retaliation would evaporate once the peace was concluded. Creutz assured the king that any “step backwards” with Franklin at this point would present “the most serious co…
  4. civic:Dumas to the American Commissioners, 27[–30] June 1778: résumé
    <The Hague, June 27[–30], in French: I have written the Grand Pensionary that the treaty has arrived, and the Grand Facteur has approved my letter. June 28: The Grand Pensionary has set our interview for tomorrow morning. Last night came your packet of the 22nd, which I devoured …
  5. correspondence:Portuguese Counterproposal for a Treaty of Amity and Commerce, [c. 7 June 1783]
    The initial negotiations for a commercial treaty between the United States and Portugal, conducted between Franklin and the conde de Sousa Coutinho, took place without the knowledge of the other American commissioners and have left no written trace. Whether Sousa Coutinho had pre…

The story ran in Reuters. A joint communiqué is already being negotiated, so much of the substance is likely settled before the three leaders sit down. That's Old News for today, and I'll be back tomorrow with another. The full episode is at ekrasworks.com/oldnews.