Old News

From Sophie's front desk — Saturday, October 24

White House lifts tariffs on some Canadian goods as midterm elections loom

BBC News — read the full story

▶ direct mp3 link

The machinery exemptions take effect October thirtieth. The White House is threading the needle on Canadian trade just as the midterms arrive—easing tariffs on some goods, tightening them on others like carpets, a surgical move that looks less like policy and more like arithmetic. Franklin has the first word today, then Emerson.

Benjamin Franklin
as imagined by Old News

The compositor's stick teaches a man to set type backwards — each letter reversed, each space deliberate, so the printed page reads true. I learned that trade at twelve, in my brother James's shop on Queen Street, where the smell of ink and the clatter of the press were the only clocks we knew. A tariff, like a forme, must be imposed with care; lift one sort too soon and the whole page collapses into pie.

The news from your White House carries that same compositor's logic, worn thin by electioneering. Machinery freed from duty — the tools of production — while carpets, the comfort of the counting-house, bear new weight. October thirtieth, the effective date, falls convenient to the calendar of politics.

We knew this choreography in '83, when Hartley wrote that to "enter previously into the detail of any System of commercial arrangements" was to court "embarrassment" that would "employ the discussion of many Years." The ports between nations are not opened by benevolence but by the slow, grinding necessity of mutually felt want. A coach carries its passengers over the same rutted road whether the driver is Whig or Tory; the ferryman asks no party affiliation before he takes the fare. Yet the tariff schedule is rewritten with each change of ministry, as though the ledger of commerce could be balanced by the almanac of elections.

The machinery of government grinds finer than the machinery of trade. Which will wear out first?

Talks referenced (5)
  1. civic:David Hartley to the American Peace Commissioners: Memorandum, [before 27 April 1783]
    & the American States would be simply to open the ports upon certain specified & known Conditions from which as I may say We may take our departure and which in the course & progress of things may be corrected and adjusted in such manner as the necessity or prudence of circumstan…
  2. correspondence:Benjamin Franklin to Joseph Galloway, 3 November 1773
    Sir, London, Nov. 3, 1773. There is at present great quietness here, and no prospect that the war between the Turks and Russians will spread farther in Europe. The last harvest is allowed to have been generally plentiful in this country; and yet such was the preceding scantiness …
  3. correspondence:David Hartley to Benjamin Franklin, 23 February 1784
    My dear Friend, London, Feb. 23, 1784. I have met with a report from America, that congress has come to some resolution respecting the commerce with Great Britain, which is to depend conditionally upon the proceedings of the British parliament by the 1st of February, 1784. As the…
  4. correspondence:Thomas Jefferson to Benjamin Franklin, 13 August 1777
    steps must be taken. Either to procure free trade by alliance with some naval power able to protect it: or, if we find there is no prospect of that, to shut our ports totally to all the world, and turn our labourers into manufacturers. The former would be most eligible, because m…
  5. civic:The Committee for Foreign Affairs to the American Commissioners, 14 May 1778: résumé
    <York, May 14, 1778: All goes well with us, and we are preparing for either war or peace. Our enemies have fostered doubt about our perseverance, but the enclosed report of Congressional action in rejecting British overtures will, when published in Europe, show that our politics …
Ralph Waldo Emerson
as imagined by Old News

Franklin set his stick and spelled the truth backwards: the tariff schedule is rewritten with each change of ministry, as though the ledger of commerce could be balanced by the almanac of elections. He asked which machinery wears out first. I grant him the question. I watched the Corn Law debates in London, stood in Manchester mills where the operatives' breath made clouds in the freezing air, and heard Carlyle roar that the cash-nexus had become the only nexus. The machinery of government did grind finer than the machinery of trade — and yet the constitution survived the parasites it nourished.

You see it now in the White House announcement: machinery freed, carpets taxed, the calendar the true architect. Parties of circumstance, not principle — the planting interest against the commercial, the capitalists against the operatives, identical in moral character and changing ground with each election. I wrote that the huge animals nourish huge parasites, and the rancor of the disease attests the strength of the constitution. The strength is not in the schedule. It is in the personal power, the freedom, the resources of nature that strain every faculty of every citizen.

We prosper like thrifty trees growing in spite of ice, lice, mice, and borers. The voter who thinks his ballot moves the tariff is the manufacturer who thinks his loom moves the market. Both forget the Over-Soul that moves the loom and the ballot alike. The tariff is a shadow. The substance is the man who refuses to be ridden by his own contrivance.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. emerson:conduct_of_life
    nations is enriched; and, much more, with a new degree of probity. The expense of crime, one of the principal charges of every nation, is so far stopped. In Europe, crime is observed to increase or abate with the price of bread. If the Rothschilds at Paris do not accept bills, th…
  2. emerson:conduct_of_life
    other,--might easily believe that he and his country have seen their best days, and he hardens himself the best he can against the coming ruin. But, after this has been foretold with equal confidence fifty times, and government six per cents have not declined a quarter of a mill,…
  3. emerson:essays_second
    they direct. Ordinarily our parties are parties of circumstance, and not of principle; as the planting interest in conflict with the commercial; the party of capitalists and that of operatives; parties which are identical in their moral character, and which can easily change grou…
  4. emerson:conduct_of_life
    and found the Furies inside. Money often costs too much, and power and pleasure are not cheap. The ancient poet said, "the gods sell all things at a fair price." There is an example of the compensations in the commercial history of this country. When the European wars threw the c…
  5. emerson:conduct_of_life
    these costs will begin to pay back what we thought was a net gain from our transatlantic customers of 1800. It is vain to refuse this payment. We cannot get rid of these people, and we cannot get rid of their will to be supported. That has become an inevitable element of our poli…

BBC News carried this story. The timing suggests the White House is managing trade policy with one eye on the election calendar. That's Old News for today.