Old News

From Sophie's front desk — Friday, October 9

US unveils sanctions on ICC in move court condemns as 'assault on rule of law'

BBC News — read the full story

▶ direct mp3 link

You've seen this shape before: a superpower sanctions an institution that claims jurisdiction over its own conduct, and the institution says the superpower just broke the law—all while the superpower insists it's defending the rule of law itself. BBC reports the US has sanctioned the International Criminal Court, with the UK and other member states pushing back hard, calling it an assault on the very thing Washington says it's protecting. The sanction is a first: no country has ever done this to the Court before. Epictetus has the first word today, then Thoreau.

Epictetus
as imagined by Old News

A master strikes the overseer who dared record his cruelty. The overseer has no whip, no garrison, only the record. The master burns the record and calls it justice. This is not about courts. It is about who decides whether the record stands. The court at The Hague holds no legions. Its authority lives only in the assent of those who could ignore it.

When the strongest refuses, the court becomes what it always was: a sentence spoken into wind. I knew a man in Rome who carried his manumission tablet like a shield. The magistrate who signed it died. The new master spat on the bronze and kept the slave. The tablet was real. The freedom was not. Freedom lives in the master's judgement, not in the bronze.

So too the law between nations. It is not the treaty. It is not the statute. It is the judgement of each sovereign whether to bind himself today, and tomorrow, and the day after. The American imperium has spoken its judgement. The court screams assault. The court is right — and the court is powerless.

What did the judges believe they possessed that was never theirs to hold?

Talks referenced (5)
  1. splice:Seneca the Younger:seneca_dialogues
    to reckon accurately the penalty for so varying a matter, we condemn it only to be hated, and place it upon the list of those crimes which we refer for judgment to the gods. VII. Many arguments occur to me which prove that this vice ought not to come under the action of the law. …
  2. splice:Seneca the Younger:seneca_dialogues
    what the law may be among you Stoic philosophers in such a case. I suppose that you keep the action which I bring against another distinct from that which he Strings against me, and the two processes are not merged into one? For instance, if a man entrusts me with money, and afte…
  3. splice:Seneca the Younger:seneca_dialogues
    subject of a judicial inquiry can be distinctly defined, and cannot afford unlimited licence to the judge; wherefore a good cause is in a better position if it before a judge than before an arbitrator, because the words of the law tie down a judge and define certain limits beyond…
  4. handbook:epictetus_enchiridion_mit
    The Internet Classics Archive | The Enchiridion by Epictetus Home Browse andComment Search Buy Books andCD-ROMs Help The Enchiridion By Epictetus Commentary: A few comments have been posted about The Enchiridion. Download: A 40k text-only version is available for download. The En…
  5. splice:Seneca the Younger:seneca_dialogues
    others out of court, and put an end to them at once. II. It is a question whether a benefit can be taken away from one by force. Some say that it cannot, because it is not a thing, but an act. A gift is not the same as the act of giving, any more than a sailor is the same as the …
Henry David Thoreau
as imagined by Old News

Epictetus named the court's scream and the master's match. He is right that the record burns. But he stops at the burning. I watched the ice go out at Walden one April. The pond does not ask permission. It does not file a brief. The ice weakens at the shore first, then the center follows — not because the center was persuaded, but because the shore gave way. The court is the center. It believed its thickness was law. The shore was always the sovereign.

You have seen this in your own woods: the ant colony that builds its mound across the path. The boot comes down. The ants do not appeal to a tribunal of boots. They carry the eggs deeper. The record of the colony is not the mound. The record is the carrying. The sanctions are the boot. They will not silence the carrying. They will only make the carrying visible. When the United States sanctions the court for investigating its allies, it teaches the world that the court's authority was always borrowed — borrowed from the very power that now revokes it.

This is not an assault on law. It is the exposure of where law actually lives: not in The Hague, but in the man who refuses to carry out the order. My prediction: the court will not collapse. It will shrink to the size of the nations still willing to fund it. The condition that would make me wrong: if a single powerful state submits to the court's judgment against its own soldiers. I have not seen that spring. The pickerel-weed pushes through the mud whether the deed is recorded or not. The pond froze. The pond thawed. The record kept itself.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. thoreau:walden
    with many on moral questions, in his chapter on the “Duty of Submission to Civil Government,” resolves all civil obligation into expediency; and he proceeds to say, “that so long as the interest of the whole society requires it, that is, so long as the established government cann…
  2. thoreau:civil_disobedience
    Luther, and pronounce Washington and Franklin rebels? One would think, that a deliberate and practical denial of its authority was the only offence never contemplated by government; else, why has it not assigned its definite, its suitable and proportionate penalty? If a man who h…
  3. thoreau:civil_disobedience
    a sixth of the population of a nation which has undertaken to be the refuge of liberty are slaves, and a whole country is unjustly overrun and conquered by a foreign army, and subjected to military law, I think that it is not too soon for honest men to rebel and revolutionize. Wh…
  4. thoreau:civil_disobedience
    the State, that the State does to the Union? And have not the same reasons prevented the State from resisting the Union, which have prevented them from resisting the State? How can a man be satisfied to entertain an opinion merely, and enjoy _it?_ Is there any enjoyment in it, if…
  5. thoreau:walden
    they cannot spare the protection of the existing government, and they dread the consequences of disobedience to it to their property and families. For my own part, I should not like to think that I ever rely on the protection of the State. But, if I deny the authority of the Stat…

The story ran in BBC News. The US sanctioned the ICC while calling it an assault on rule of law—a move that only works if you believe you stand outside the system you're dismantling. That's the brief.