From Sophie's front desk — Wednesday, November 11
BBC News — read the full story
Watch the Slideo →Russia and Ukraine met in Abu Dhabi to sketch a security framework for Europe after the war, and they left with nothing agreed. BBC News reports the talks ended without a breakthrough, but the diplomatic track is still moving. US envoys are due to meet Putin and Zelensky on Thursday. Seneca takes the first pass at what a settlement built on exhaustion can actually hold, then Benjamin Franklin comes in on the bargaining and the practical terms.
They met in Abu Dhabi talking peace while the guns still spoke louder than their words. Abu Dhabi—neutral sand, cool marble, the sort of place where men in fine clothes sip coffee and sketch lines on maps as if borders were ink that could be redrawn without blood soaking the paper underneath.
Russia wants guarantees that NATO will never creep closer; Ukraine wants ironclad promises that if the invader returns, the world will not look away again. Both sides spoke in the language of security, but what they really traded was fear—each afraid the other’s paper shield will crack the moment it is tested.
No breakthrough came because neither trusts the other’s signature enough to lay down arms first, and neither believes the guarantors will stay when the cameras leave. So the diplomats pack their briefs and fly home while the trenches hold, and the question hangs: what does security mean when the only thing keeping the peace is the exhaustion of both sides?
Is a ceasefire that rests on weariness truly security, or merely the pause before the next storm?
which have stood the shock of civil and foreign wars crash to the ground though no one sets them tottering. How few the states which have carried their good fortune through to the end! We should therefore reflect upon all contingencies, and should fortify our minds against the ev…
peace and security? He would not have recognized the good which he had himself bestowed, and would hardly have believed, when he looked back upon himself, that so great a man could have been born in his house. Why should I go on to speak of others who would now be forgotten, if t…
What, then, is the conclusion of the matter? It was by reason of their ignorance of things that the men of those days were innocent; and it makes a great deal of difference whether one wills not to sin or has not the knowledge to sin. Justice was unknown to them, unknown prudence…
events the issues of the most admirable projects, though we ought to praise the will itself which makes an effort in the right direction. Even though another passes it by with swifter pace, yet the palm of victory does not, as in publicly-exhibited races, declare which is the bet…
extend the boundaries of your estates? An estate which held a nation is too narrow for a single lord. How far will you push forward your ploughed fields—you who are not content to confine the measure of your farms even within the amplitude of provinces? You have noble rivers flow…
Seneca gave the same condition the name exhaustion. I call it theater — and I have sat in enough diplomatic chambers to know the difference between a treaty and a truce. In Abu Dhabi the marble is cool, the coffee fine, and the maps spread flat as if borders were ink one might blot and redraw. At Versailles, Franklin refused Hartley's paper commission because it lacked the Great Seal; he knew a document without the weight of sovereign authority is merely expensive stationery.
These envoys trade security frameworks while the guns speak in a language no memorandum understands. Each side sells its constituency the ghost of an ending while positioning for the continuation. The American commissioners in Paris 1783 faced the same charade — Hartley's supplemental treaty, the Russian mediator's polite smiles, the Dutch draft arriving clause by clause. We negotiated the peace separately because we learned that a security framework imposed by mediators becomes a cage for the mediated.
Locke would have smiled at the symmetry: men consent to government to escape the state of war, yet here sovereigns consent to talks to remain in it. A pause is not a peace. A framework signed in air-conditioned marble holds no more than the parchment it is written on when the powder is still wet in the barrels. The only security that lasts is the balance of interests that makes violation costlier than observance.
Everything else is merely the interval between volleys.
be ready to enter on negociations, & receive propositions which might be of mutual advantage and tend to cement the Union & increase the harmony which prevailed between the two nations.” A draft treaty between the United States and Denmark had already been sent to Congress. Baron…
may not have wanted to lecture the veteran diplomats Franklin and Adams, who, in their previous negotiations of treaties of commerce, had followed the customary language of longstanding European treaties. Finally, he prepared Memorandum (II), which posed additional questions to h…
On Tuesday, July 1, at the weekly gathering of ministers at Versailles, Vergennes informed the American peace commissioners that the Anglo-French treaty had been settled, pending British approval, and the time had come for them to pay official visits to the Russian and Austrian m…
Formal negotiations between the United States and Great Britain to establish a trade agreement and conclude the definitive peace treaty broke down almost immediately over the exchange of credentials. When Franklin, Adams, Jay, and Laurens met with British representative David Har…
based on the Franco-American Treaty of Amity and Commerce, with a few additions taken from the recently concluded Dutch-American treaty. Finding that the two proposals differed “in several points,” Creutz sought further instructions from his court, informing Gustavus III that he …
The story ran in BBC News. Drafting a security framework for after a war is the easy part on paper; the hard part is whether either side trusts who enforces it. That's Old News for today, and I'll see you tomorrow with another. The full episode is at ekrasworks.com/oldnews.