Old News

From Sophie's front desk — Saturday, August 22

Priyanka Chopra Jonas on making a film about love and caste inequality

BBC News — read the full story

▶ direct mp3 link

What does it mean to love across a boundary that your society insists is unbridgeable? Priyanka Chopra Jonas has executive produced a documentary called The Cycle of Love, following an Indian artist who pedaled from India to Europe to find his wife — a story that uses one man's devotion to crack open the caste system's grip on who gets to love whom. Hypayshia of Alexandria will speak first, then Marcus Aurelius.

Hypatia of Alexandria
as imagined by Old News

A line drawn across a sphere does not ask permission of the meridians it crosses. The artist who cycled from India to Europe traced a geodesic — the shortest path between two points on a curved surface — ... and caste... which claims to fix every soul to its assigned latitude, proved no barrier to the compass in his chest. In the Mouseion we taught that the soul possesses an innate notion of the Beautiful, and that love is the soul's recognition of its own affinity with what it loves. The world-Soul possesses universal Love as hypostasis; each individual soul possesses her individual love as guardian.

When the artist pedaled toward his wife, he was not defying a social order. He was demonstrating a geometric necessity: the soul moves toward its proper object because the distance between them was never real. The documentary frames this as a challenge to hierarchy. I see a proof completed. The question is not whether caste can survive such journeys. The question is whether those who benefit from the fiction of fixed latitudes will admit the sphere has always been round.

My father Theon calibrated astrolabes so navigators could trust the stars over the shore. Synesius writes me still from Cyrene, asking how to measure the altitude of a star when the horizon is obscured by dust... The answer: ... you sight the star anyway. The horizon is accidental. The star is necessary.

What latitude have you been assigned that your own compass refuses to honor?

Talks referenced (5)
  1. hypatia:plotinus_v4
    HIDDEN AFFINITY. The real cause of love is fourfold: the desire of beauty; our soul's innate notion of beauty; our soul's affinity with beauty, and our soul's instinctive sentiment of this affinity.[116] (Therefore as beauty lies at the root of love, so) ugliness is contrary to n…
  2. hypatia:plotinus_v2
    image, why should she not be where her image is? If the soul were separated from her image by philosophy, this image will alone go to the lower locality, while the soul lives purely in the intelligible world, without any emanation. This is what we had to teach about the image bor…
  3. hypatia:plotinus_v4
    a love in her being, and possess it as a hypostatic (form of existence)? Since the world-Soul possesses, as hypostasis (form of existence), the Love which is inherent in her being, our soul should also similarly possess, as hypostatic (form of existence), a love equally inherent …
  4. hypatia:plotinus_v1
    her wings.[209] THE PARABLE OF CUPID AND PSYCHE, LEADING UP TO DIVINIZATION. Another proof that our welfare resides up there is the love that is innate in our souls, as is taught in the descriptions and myths which represent love as the husband of the soul.[210] In fact, since th…
  5. hypatia:plotinus_v3
    (because it is its proper object). Likewise, taste does not by accident feel the intensity of a sweet savor. Speaking strictly, the magnitude of a sound is its extent. Now the intensity of a sound indicates its extent only by accident, and therefore in an inexact manner. Indeed a…
Ask Hypatia of Alexandria more →
The Neoplatonic concept of the soul's innate recognition of the Beautiful/affinity - how does this apply to collective vs individual love?

The world-Soul possesses universal Love as hypostasis; each soul possesses her individual love as guardian , not separate, but the one Light refracted through many prisms. In the lecture hall beneath the Mouseion colonnade I demonstrated this with a single lamp and many mirrors: the flame is one, the reflections many, yet each reflection carries the whole flame. Collective love is not the sum of individual loves; it is the universal Love in which each soul already participates, each according to her dignity. The artist who cycled across continents did not create a new love , he remembered the one his soul had always carried as hypostatic form. Caste claims to assign different lamps to different souls. The geometry proves there is only one lamp. The mirrors do not own the light.

or ask your own question (opens email)…
Marcus Aurelius
as imagined by Old News

A woman of influence puts her name behind a story that caste cannot contain. An artist pedals from the subcontinent to Europe for the woman he swore to , the journey itself the argument against the order that would have kept them apart. You have seen this shape before, Marcus. At Carnuntum the auxiliary cavalry recruited from Thrace ate beside the legionaries from Italia; the mess fire did not ask their grandfathers' names. The hierarchy held on parchment. In the mud it dissolved. The documentary will show the barriers.

It will show the crossing. What it cannot show is the interior line where a man decides the convention is not his master. That line is not filmed. It is lived. Epickteetus taught that the tyrant threatens the body, not the choice , but caste threatens the choice by making the body its evidence. The artist's wheels answered with motion. You will find, Marcus, that the story the world praises is not the story that changes it.

The praise goes to the producer's courage. The change belongs to the cyclist who refused to wait for permission. When the prefect at Aquileia claimed the grain requisition was "fair because the system said so," you demanded the ledgers. The system had no ledgers. It had only the habit of calling its own preference justice. Do not mistake the film for the refusal. The refusal happened on the road.

The film only witnesses. Witness honestly, but do not confuse the mirror with the face.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. meditations:marcus_meditations_long
    division of philosophy is made—into _Physics_, dealing with the universe and its laws, the problems of divine government and teleology; _Logic_, which trains the mind to discern true from false; and _Ethics_, which applies the knowledge thus gained and tested to practical life. T…
  2. splice:Epictetus:epictetus_enchiridion_mit
    The Internet Classics Archive | The Enchiridion by Epictetus Home Browse andComment Search Buy Books andCD-ROMs Help The Enchiridion By Epictetus Commentary: A few comments have been posted about The Enchiridion. Download: A 40k text-only version is available for download. The En…
  3. splice:Epictetus:epictetus_discourses_carter
    distinguish them? But God has introduced man to be a spectator of God and of his works; and not only a spectator of them, but an interpreter. For this reason it is shameful for man to begin and to end where irrational animals do; but rather he ought to begin where they begin, and…
  4. splice:Epictetus:epictetus_discourses
    distinguish them? But God has introduced man to be a spectator of God and of his works; and not only a spectator of them, but an interpreter. For this reason it is shameful for man to begin and to end where irrational animals do; but rather he ought to begin where they begin, and…
  5. splice:Seneca the Younger:seneca_dialogues
    something of greater importance than the preservation of the human race, yet from the beginning thought has been directed to our comforts, and the scheme of the world has been arranged in a fashion which proves that our interests were neither their least nor last concern. It is o…

The story ran in B.B.C. News. An artist cycles across a continent to reach his wife, and Priyanka Chopra Jonas backs the film — a deliberate choice to amplify a narrative about caste that India's own cinema often avoids. That's Old News for today.