Old News

From Sophie's front desk — Monday, November 2

'Going hungry': Garment workers in Bangladesh say wages barely cover needs

Al Jazeera — read the full story

▶ direct mp3 link

"Going hungry"—that's what the workers call it in Bangladesh, where they're marching for wages that might actually let them eat. Al Jazeera has the dispatch: thousands of garment workers, the backbone of the world's second-largest apparel export industry, are saying their paychecks don't cover basic needs. The math is simple and brutal—current minimum wages leave them choosing between food and rent. Benjamin Franklin thought this worth a word, and Henry David Thoreau after him.

Benjamin Franklin
as imagined by Old News

I read of Bangladesh, where the looms never cease and the women who tend them cannot buy the cloth they make. The headline says hunger. I have seen hunger in Philadelphia, too — not in the almanac, but in the composing room at midnight, when the journeyman counts his wages against the rent and finds the sum wanting. You ask whether the market will correct it. I wrote once that the laboring poor receive, in the aggregate, the whole revenue of the nation — every farthing the rich expend returns to them as wages. A pretty circularity.

But the circle has a gap: the merchant who sells dear and pays cheap keeps the difference, and the worker eats air. At the Convention in '87, we argued whether Congress should regulate commerce. The Southern delegates feared interference with their labor system; the Northern, interference with their manufactures. We compromised. The loom kept turning. The compromise held — until it did not.

A master printer in London once raised his compositors' wages by a shilling, saying a fed man sets better type. His competitors called him mad. His profit rose. The competitors copied him. The market corrected — upward. The cloth does not weave itself.

The wage is not a gift but a claim.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. correspondence:On the Laboring Poor, [April 1768]
    and to their underworking one another in order to obtain employment. How is this to be remedied? A law might be made to raise their wages; but if our manufactures are too dear, they will not vend abroad, and all that part of employment will fail, unless by fighting and conquering…
  2. correspondence:On the Laboring Poor, [April 1768]
    do, consider every encrease of wages, only as something that enables them to drink more and work less; so that their distress in sickness, age, or times of scarcity, continues to be the same as if such laws had never been made in their favour. Much malignant censure have some wri…
  3. correspondence:On the Laboring Poor, [April 1768]
    hands of the impoverished, whose necessities oblige them to sell; and thus this difference is equalled. I allow also, that part of the expence of the rich is in foreign produce or manufactures, for producing which the labouring poor of other nations must be paid; but then I say, …
  4. correspondence:“Arator”: On the Price of Corn, and Management of the Poor, [29 November 1766]
    be it so; they cannot be less thankful than those I have been used to feed. Are we Farmers the only people to be grudged the profits of honest labour? And why? One of the late scribblers against us gives a bill of fare of the provisions at my daughter’s wedding, and proclaims to …
  5. correspondence:Benjamin Franklin to the Printer of The London Chronicle, 30 December 1758
    Sir, When people consider the supply of Twelve Millions as necessary for the service of the ensuing year, the greatness of the object astonishes; and they are apt to say, Whence can so vast a sum arise? Can England possibly bear the continuance of a war at so enormous an expence?…
Henry David Thoreau
as imagined by Old News

Franklin saw the composing room and called it solved — feed the man, the type sets straighter, the ledger balances. I knew John Field on the Baker Farm, an Irish bogger with a wife and children in a hut that leaked when the spring freshet rose. He worked the neighbor's meadow from dawn until the swallows cut the air, and his wage bought salt pork and coarse meal and the rent on the very ground he manured.

The farmer who hired him was a decent man by the light of the village; he paid the going rate and thought it fair. The market had corrected, as Franklin says it does. And Field remained a bogger, his days mortgaged to another's crop, his children raised to the same hoe.

I watched the pickerel-weed in the shallows this July — each leaf holds its own stem, draws its own nutrient from the mud, asks no master for a share of the light. The ants on the pine stump carry their burden and the burden is their own. No foreman times them.

The ice went out on Walden last April with a sound like thunder cracking the hills, and no merchant's schedule hurried it. The headline from Bangladesh reaches me across the wire, but the pickerel-weed asked no master for its share of the light, and the ice went out on its own schedule.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. thoreau:walden
    the farm. He was only a little more weather-beaten than when I saw him last. I have heard of a dog that barked at every stranger who approached his master’s premises with clothes on, but was easily quieted by a naked thief. It is an interesting question how far men would retain t…
  2. thoreau:civil_disobedience
    crisis? “A drab of state, a cloth-o’-silver slut, To have her train borne up, and her soul trail in the dirt.” Practically speaking, the opponents to a reform in Massachusetts are not a hundred thousand politicians at the South, but a hundred thousand merchants and farmers here, …
  3. thoreau:walden
    vital heat, and secondly, in this state of society, to cover nakedness, and he may judge how much of any necessary or important work may be accomplished without adding to his wardrobe. Kings and queens who wear a suit but once, though made by some tailor or dressmaker to their ma…
  4. thoreau:walden
    anything to say. “Tell the tailors,” said he, “to remember to make a knot in their thread before they take the first stitch.” His companion’s prayer is forgotten. However mean your life is, meet it and live it; do not shun it and call it hard names. It is not so bad as you are. I…
  5. thoreau:walden
    worship God in, they will do; will they not? Who ever saw his old clothes,—his old coat, actually worn out, resolved into its primitive elements, so that it was not a deed of charity to bestow it on some poor boy, by him perchance to be bestowed on some poorer still, or shall we …

Al Jazeera carried the story. Bangladesh exports half the world's cheap clothes, and the people making them can't afford to eat—a supply-chain economics problem wrapped in a wage problem. That's Old News for today.