Old News

From Sophie's front desk — Thursday, October 8

Protesters blame 'vulture funds' for Spain's housing crisis

BBC News — read the full story

▶ direct mp3 link

Madrid's streets are filling with tents. BBC reports hundreds of protesters blaming investment funds—"vulture funds," they call them—for pricing ordinary people out of housing, and Spain's Prime Minister just called a snap election because the problem won't wait. Franklin gets the first word, then Emerson.

Benjamin Franklin
as imagined by Old News

I sat in the London Coffee House on Threadneedle Street in '68 and watched the jobbers bid up East India stock until a clerk's yearly wage would not buy a single share. The talk was all of "monied interest" — a phrase new to me then, though the thing itself was old as the first mortgage. Now your Madrid protesters pitch tents against "vulture funds." The name is new. The beast is not. Here is the question they argue: whether the fund or the family owns the roof. The wrong question.

The right one — the one Peter Collinson put to me over a dissecting knife in '53 — is why capital that could build tenements flows instead to buy the debt on tenements already built. I saw it in the Pennsylvania land office: speculators held warrants for thousands of acres while settlers slept in bark huts. The warrants produced no grain, no hearth, no child raised dry. They produced only a ledger entry that could be sold to the next speculator at a profit. A maxim: Capital follows the path of least resistance to its own increase. The counter-example: the Loan Office of '69, where we lent at six percent to men who built houses, and the houses stood.

The money returned. The community held. Your protesters ask for rent caps. The Prime Minister calls an election. Neither touches the pipe that carries the money. Stop the flow into extraction, and it will find construction — because shelter, unlike a bond, cannot be eaten by interest.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. correspondence:Benjamin Franklin to William Franklin, 13 March 1768
    papers. The parliament is up and the nation in a ferment with the new elections. Great complaints are made that the natural interests of country gentlemen in their neighbouring boroughs, is overborne by the monied interest of the new people who have got sudden fortunes in the Ind…
  2. correspondence:[Benjamin Vaughan] to Benjamin Franklin, 6 September 1778
    Lord North and Ld. G: Germaine in disavowing their former intentions and declarations respecting America: But being at a distance from the centre of news, are not yet warmed. However they have burned the above gentlemen in effigy at Durham; and a certain Welch dignitary (your fri…
  3. correspondence:David Hartley to Benjamin Franklin, 29 June 1779
    a settlement of their own matters in dispute, before any final settlement of the then subsisting disturbances between the contending parties shd be suffered to take effect, I can easily imagine that spain might think it necessary to accelerate its pace, if any idea had got abroad…
  4. correspondence:The Question Discussed, [19 November 1774]
    should we smite Ireland and the West Indies? I answer, The funds which support the Irish linen manufacture, and the West-India plantations, lie very much in London; the linen of Ireland, and the produce of the West-Indies, are mostly due to London before they are made, and theref…
  5. correspondence:Benjamin Franklin to the Printer of The London Chronicle, 30 December 1758
    Sir, When people consider the supply of Twelve Millions as necessary for the service of the ensuing year, the greatness of the object astonishes; and they are apt to say, Whence can so vast a sum arise? Can England possibly bear the continuance of a war at so enormous an expence?…
Ralph Waldo Emerson
as imagined by Old News

Benjamin Franklin watched the jobbers bid up East India stock in a London coffee house and called the pipe by its name. He was right about the pipe. He stopped short of the water. I have seen the daguerreotype plate catch a face in thirty seconds — the sitter holds still, the mercury vapor does its work, and there the likeness stands, fixed in silver. You cannot argue with the image. The crisis in Madrid is not about housing.

It is about the image men have made of property, and the violence they do to the soul to keep the image intact. In the winter of '62 I walked the Concord ridge while the telegraph brought word of Fredericksburg. Twelve thousand casualties in a single afternoon. The papers called it strategy. The mothers called it theft. The same hand that signed the mortgage on a Madrid flat today signed the conscription order then — property defending property, calling it law.

Only Love, only an Idea, is against property as we hold it. The funds are not vultures. They are the mirror. When the Prime Minister calls his election he asks the mirror to change its face. A good tree agrees with the soil. The rest is pruning.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. emerson:essays_second
    property. Only Love, only an Idea, is against property as we hold it. I cannot afford to be irritable and captious, nor to waste all my time in attacks. If I should go out of church whenever I hear a false sentiment I could never stay there five minutes. But why come out? the str…
  2. emerson:conduct_of_life
    these costs will begin to pay back what we thought was a net gain from our transatlantic customers of 1800. It is vain to refuse this payment. We cannot get rid of these people, and we cannot get rid of their will to be supported. That has become an inevitable element of our poli…
  3. emerson:essays_second
    rate. Fear, Craft, and Avarice Cannot rear a State. Out of dust to build What is more than dust,-- Walls Amphion piled Phoebus stablish must. When the Muses nine With the Virtues meet, Find to their design An Atlantic seat, By green orchard boughs Fended from the heat, Where the …
  4. emerson:conduct_of_life
    is question, every spring, whether to graft with wax, or whether with clay; whether to whitewash or to potash, or to prune; but the one point is the thrifty tree. A good tree, that agrees with the soil, will grow in spite of blight, or bug, or pruning, or neglect, by night and by…
  5. emerson:essays_second
    is timid, and merely defensive of property. It vindicates no right, it aspires to no real good, it brands no crime, it proposes no generous policy; it does not build, nor write, nor cherish the arts, nor foster religion, nor establish schools, nor encourage science, nor emancipat…

The story ran in BBC News. Spain's snap election call proves housing has become too political to ignore—when speculation displaces people faster than governments can respond, the math stops being economic. That's Old News for today.