Old News

From Sophie's front desk — Wednesday, November 11

Iran warns of expanded retaliation as Israel reportedly readies to attack

Al Jazeera — read the full story

Watch the Slideo →
The conversation on the page, with pullouts, context and sources as they speak
▶ direct mp3 link

Israel's security cabinet has reportedly ordered its military to step up preparations for a possible strike on Iran. Al Jazeera, drawing on Israeli media, reports that Tehran has answered by warning any attack will bring a wider retaliation. The escalation lands while US-Iran peace talks remain unresolved and Iran's missile programme is still in dispute. Seneca takes the first word on what restraint costs a power already counting its options, and then Benjamin Franklin answers on how a nation keeps its nerve when the arithmetic turns against it.

Seneca
as imagined by Old News

Israel's cabinet has ordered its military to prepare a strike on Iran. Iran says any attack will bring a wider war. The question every capital is arguing — who strikes first, who is justified, what counts as proportionate — is the wrong question. The right question is what becomes of the people caught between two powers that have made retaliation their policy. Nero decided that a suspected plot justified killing his mother, his tutor, and his wife.

Each killing was called necessary. Each killing made the next one easier. The logic does not stop at the border. A feud grows without anyone agreeing to it. It feeds on the certainty that the other side started it.

The missiles, the centrifuges, the rhetoric — these are only the weapons the logic reaches for. The logic itself is the enemy. I think of the gladiators at midday, how they saluted the emperor before butchering each other for a crowd that had already forgotten their names. The arena ignores which side you chose. It only cares that you entered.

Send me word when the dust settles. If it settles.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. letters:seneca_letters_gummere
    action an army prepared to meet death for their wives and children, how will he exhort them to battle? I remind you of the Fabii, who took upon a single clan a war which concerned the whole state. I point out to you the Lacedaemonians in position at the very pass of Thermopylae! …
  2. letters:seneca_letters_gummere
    attack in one way, or even with her full strength; at one time she summons our own hands against us; at another time, content with her own powers, she makes use of no agent in devising perils for us. No time is exempt; in the midst of our very pleasures there spring up causes of …
  3. letters:seneca_letters_gummere
    men have been robbed, blackmailed, slain, betrayed, stamped under foot, attacked by poison or by slander; no matter what trouble you mention, it has happened to many. Again, there are manifold kinds of missiles which are hurled at us. Some are planted in us, some are being brandi…
  4. letters:seneca_letters_gummere
    which have stood the shock of civil and foreign wars crash to the ground though no one sets them tottering. How few the states which have carried their good fortune through to the end! We should therefore reflect upon all contingencies, and should fortify our minds against the ev…
  5. dialogues:seneca_dialogues
    that you may be put to flight. The Greeks will yield up many parts of their country to you, as if they were swept out of them by the first terrible rush of a mountain torrent; afterwards they will rise against you from all quarters and will crush you by means of your own strength…
Benjamin Franklin
as imagined by Old News

Seneca calls the arena; I call the counting-house. When Vergennes told us in '78 that the British cabinet would offer independence if we made separate peace, we set aside who struck first and what was proportionate, and asked only whether the ink on our treaty with France had dried. It had.

Congress answered as Vergennes expected. The missiles of that day were French ships of the line; the peace talks took place in Paris and nowhere in Vienna; and the wider war came anyway because the calculation of interest moves nations and the calculus of justice does not. A printer in Philadelphia set type for a proclamation one week and a declaration of war the next — the same composing stick, the same ink, the same hands, the same night.

In the arena, your choice of side counts for nothing. The counting-house asks only who pays. The bill always comes due, and the interest compounds.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. civic:Franklin and John Adams to the President of Congress, 23 July 1778: résumé
    <Passy, July 23, 1778: We are informed by the Count de Vergennes that the British cabinet plans to offer independence to the United States if it will make a separate peace. M. de Vergennes requests us to inform Congress that war between Britain and France, though not formally dec…
  2. correspondence:The Swedish-American Treaty of Amity and Commerce, with Translation, 3 April [i.e., 5 March] 1783
    accompanying dispatch from the president of the Chancellery, that the king’s concerns about potential British retaliation would evaporate once the peace was concluded. Creutz assured the king that any “step backwards” with Franklin at this point would present “the most serious co…
  3. civic:The American Commissioners to Vergennes, [before 9 January 1779]: résumé
    abhorred by all civilized nations. Heretofore, exasperated as our people have been, they have been exhorted to forbearance and acts of humanity. But now, faced with published threats, Congress has resolved to retaliate. We ask whether His Majesty might issue a declaration to the …
  4. civic:Dumas to the American Commissioners, 9 June 1778: résumé
    <The Hague, June 9, 1778, in French: The enclosed will show that war in Germany may be expected any day. An anti-British pamphlet has recently appeared, dedicated to Mr. Franklin; it is badly done but has attracted many important readers. I and the Grand Facteur and the Grand Pen…
  5. correspondence:Thomas Digges to Benjamin Franklin, 31 May[–1 June] 1779
    is the probable inexpediency of prosecuting the war in America, for since the American Enquiry before the Ho. of commons, some parts of the Admn hold this kind of language. If they had been wise they would have made these kind of enquirys before they fought & became disgracd. It …

Al Jazeera carried the story. Orders to prepare tend to narrow the options long before anyone decides to use them. That's Old News for today. The full episode is at ekrasworks.com/oldnews.