From Sophie's front desk — Sunday, October 11
NYT — read the full story
"In Canada's Arctic, a new generation of Inuit creatives are using identity to fuel their art," the New York Times reports from Iqaluit, where artists working in one of the world's most isolated capitals are centering indigenous perspective as both cultural reclamation and global contribution. Iqaluit accessible only by air or seasonal sealift—the geography itself becomes part of the artistic claim. Hypatia of Alexandria has the first word today, then Alan Watts.
I have watched the scrolls burn in the Serapeum. You stood beside me in the ash and asked whether the diagram still holds when the hall that housed it is gone. The Inuit artists in your northern Iqaluit — reachable only by air or the seasonal sealift, you say — are drawing new diagrams on old ground. Their forms are particular: the seal, the ice, the language that shaped itself to wind. But the structure they follow is universal. Matter receives form without becoming it.
The intelligible world contains the idea of Artist, not this artist or that one. Yet every particular work proves the universal by surviving its own making. We in Alexandria knew this. Theon taught me that the astrolabe's rete turns the same heavens whether the brass is forged in Rome or cast in a workshop beside the Harbor. The calculation does not care whose hands hold the rule. But the hands matter.
They are the location where the eternal enters time. Your Inuit makers are not reclaiming identity as a banner. They are demonstrating that the universal — symmetry, rhythm, the proportion that governs both ice-crystal and carving — does not float free. It requires a people, a place, a tongue to become visible. When the next empire decides their forms are primitive, the work will not vanish. It will have already proved what no decree can touch: that beauty is the trace of the One in the many.
The condition that would falsify this is simple: show me a culture that produces no symmetry, no rhythm, no proportion — and I will concede the universal was never there.
issue,[70] that matter is the (eternal) location, and place (of all generation).[71] MATTER AS LOCATION OF FORMS REMAINS IMPASSIBLE. When Plato, rightfully, calls matter "the location of forms," he is not thereby attributing any passion to matter; he only indicates that matters g…
is a state of matter, or of anything similar to matter, which failed to be completely assimilated.[143] SOME ARTS ARE PURELY EARTHLY; OTHERS, LIKE MUSIC, INTELLIGIBLE. 11. Let us therefore consider the arts and their products. Unless as represented within human reason, we cannot …
also with philosophy, which occupies the first rank among sciences because it studies essence. This is all we have to say about arts and their products. THE INTELLIGIBLE WORLD CONTAINS ONLY UNIVERSAL IDEAS; PARTICULARITIES ARE DERIVED FROM MATTER. 12. If the intelligible world co…
the question to which of them memory belongs. If memory belong to both kinds of imagination, there will always be two kinds of imagination--for it cannot be said that the memory of intelligible things belongs to the one, and that of sense-things to the other; otherwise we would h…
begat an inferior form, which, passing into matter, could neither preserve all its purity, nor completely respond to the will of the artist, possessing no perfection other than that allowed by matter. As the nature of art is to produce beauty, if art succeed in producing beauty w…
Hypatia saw the diagram in the ash and called it beauty. I was at King's School Canterbury when the masters still believed character was something you built like a wall, brick by Latin brick — and the IBM mainframe at the ministry was already sorting us into punch-card categories before we knew our own names. The Inuit artists in Iqaluit are told their identity is the fuel, the raw material, the brand. But identity is not the fire. It is the smoke. You see, when the hunters of my boyhood stories tracked the seal, they did not carry a banner saying "I am a hunter." They became the tracking.
The moment you make identity the subject, you have already stepped out of the dance and into the gallery. The IBM machine does not know this. It only counts. And the curators count the counts. Now the young carvers in the north are exquisite, yes — but the market wants their "Inuit-ness" packaged, and they are learning to package it. That is not reclamation.
That is a new kind of sealift. The diagram Hypatia loved? It holds. But it holds precisely because no one is watching it hold. The circle drawn on the blackboard is not the circle. The wall with the hole in it — that is the one the wind moves through.
is worth a hundred sayings,” the expression of Zen in the arts gives us one of the most direct ways of understanding it. This is the more so because the art forms which Zen has created are not symbolic in the same way as other types of Buddhist art, or as is “religious” art as a …
stuff. Thus Malraux speaks always of the artist “conquering” his medium as our explorers and scientists also speak of conquering mountains or conquer- ing space. To Chinese and Japanese ears these are grotesque ex- pressions. For when you climb it is the mountain as much as your …
the self. In the known history of humans, there have been three types of cultures—I’ll call them hunting, agrarian, and industrial. Hunting cultures came first, and agrarian cultures arose when hunters settled in certain areas and learned to farm, which led to established communi…
about little birds where they’re cold and they’re all huddling together. The idea being to see who can get most inside and human beings are just like that. And so also is everything else. Because, this is a an absolutely basic requirement of having an identity. To have an identit…
culture, you must not make any image of any living creature. And so their art, very interestingly, one must admit, went off into abstract patterning. But what one is saying here is not that it is somehow just wrong to make an image. The point is much deeper than that. It is this.…
The story ran in The New York Times. A generation of Inuit artists in Iqaluit is building contemporary work from their own cultural ground instead of inheriting someone else's frame—which is how you actually get new aesthetics, not new versions of the old ones. That's Old News for today.