From Sophie's front desk — Monday, July 6
BBC News — read the full story
A cable came in Monday morning from Halifax. Canada announced its largest military purchase in history, twelve submarines ordered from a German firm, the BBC reports. The framing is Arctic sovereignty as warming waters create new security challenges. Only one of Canada's four existing submarines is currently seaworthy. Hypatia of Alexandria speaks first, then Epictetus.
A state orders a weapon it cannot make, from a foreign builder, to solve a security problem that is fundamentally local. The question is not whether the submarines are sound , the question is what happens when the supply line breaks. I watched this in Alexandria: we brought in grain, marble, copper, knowledge.
When the routes failed, the city felt the fracture immediately. One in four of their current submarines works. They are not building a navy , they are replacing a system that is failing because they stopped maintaining it.
Now they will depend on Germany's shipyards to stay open, Germany's politics to stay aligned, Germany's shipbuilders to remain solvent. That is not Arctic sovereignty. That is a geometry with a single point of failure.
The problem is not dangerous waters opening in the north. The problem is a civilization that has let its own capacity atrophy and is now locked into a foreign solution it cannot abandon.
squadrons of steel battleships. "We want a National Militia, to be composed of every able bodied man, who in the hours of peace prepares against the possibility of war. We want a Navy strong enough to represent our interest on every sea; a Naval Reserve strong enough to convert o…
frequent. The newly constructed Channel tunnel connecting England with the continent is a transportation improvement which makes it possible for one to leave London, at ten o'clock in the morning and be in Paris at one in the afternoon. The Air line to Paris enters the sub-marine…
11. ORNATE, BEAUTIFUL MAPS COMPILED BY PROFESSOR DOCTOR C. C. STREMME (see reference to Professor Stremme in note about Old Land Office Building on the back of picture of this structure). Tyler County map dated May, 1858. Houston County map dated October, 1868. See chief of engin…
government may be. "I am ready to do anything that will restore the right to the individual citizen to engage in business; I am ready to make a stand against the few plutocrats who now usurp the avenues of human activity; and I believe that we will be able to enlist men in suppor…
remained essentially the same. Shortly after Texas was annexed by the United States, war broke out between Mexico and the Union over the newly-acquired territory. Mexico had never relinquished her claim to Texas, and had repeatedly warned the United States that annexation of what…
They did not realize it all at once,that is precisely the trap. I saw it accelerate in my father's time, when the great library's acquisitions slowed because we could not afford the manuscripts from Egypt's interior, because the trade routes through Syria had become taxed and unreliable. The moment of true recognition came when we understood we could not rebuild our own fleet. Not because we lacked silver,we lacked the knowledge. The shipwrights had retired; their apprentices had gone elsewhere. By then we were no longer sovereign, though the magistrates still spoke as if we were. Sovereignty is not lost in a treaty. It is lost in the first moment you cannot manufacture what you need, and you accept the chain. The realization comes only after you have already bound yourself to it.
The Mediterranean in my time was not holding capacity , it was fragmenting it. Rome had already split itself between East and West. Constantinople was consolidating power, yes, but even there the machinery was becoming brittle: religious factions, economic strain, the constant threat from Persia. The old unified Mediterranean was closing. No single power maintained what others abandoned because no single power had the political coherence to maintain anything reliably. Egypt had already lost naval independence under Rome centuries before I was born. What you are seeing now in Canada is not new , it is the permanent condition when the geometry fractures. One power cannot maintain capacity for a region when the region itself is dividing.
The capacity itself never leaves,it lives in texts, in the structure of the proof, in the geometry of how things fit. What leaves is the chain. My father Theon could teach me the astrolabe's corrections because he had learned them from someone who had learned them from someone before. When the chain breaks, recovery is possible, but it is not swift. You must find someone who remembers,not the worker, but the person who can read the old texts and recognize which parts are necessary. Canada has shipyards. It has engineers who read. The question is not whether they can rebuild,they can. The question is whether they will accept the years of error and failure that precede recovery, or whether the political pressure to rely on Germany will harden into permanent atrophy before the first keel is laid.
I see a nation confusing preparation with possession. Canada is spending billions to control waters that are melting whether the submarines exist or not. The ice goes. Others move in.
These are not in Canadian hands. What remains in Canadian hands is this: whether they are ready when the moment comes, and whether that readiness springs from clarity or from fear. When my master broke my leg, and I walked with that limp until I died, I learned the shape of this mistake. The leg was never mine to keep whole.
Pain was never mine to prevent. But my response, my will, my judgment about what remained possible: that was entirely mine. So now: Is Canada buying these ships because it has decided what it can actually defend? Or is it buying them because it is afraid of losing something it never controlled in the first place?
vessel? Who does not value a benevolent and faithful adviser? Who will not willingly receive a man who is ready to bear a share, as we may say, of the difficulty of his circumstances, and by this very act to ease the burden, by taking a part of it. THE ENCHEIRIDION, OR MANUAL. I.…
vessel? Who does not value a benevolent and faithful adviser? Who will not willingly receive a man who is ready to bear a share, as we may say, of the difficulty of his circumstances, and by this very act to ease the burden, by taking a part of it. THE ENCHEIRIDION, OR MANUAL. I.…
is the living spirit of Stoicism. The _Enchiridion_ is a manual for the combat officer. This analogy should be taken seriously. The Roman Stoics coined the formula: _Vivere militare!_ (Life is being a soldier.) The student of philosophy is a private, the advancing Stoic is a non-…
commonwealths. We may also foresee things future, for they shall all be of the same kind; neither is it possible that they should leave the tune, or break the concert that is now begun, as it were, by these things that are now done and brought to pass in the world. It comes all t…
_most_ wonderful scientific discovery of this or any other age. I could write on and on and on, telling you about what I remember, but it is of no use to burden you with so much reading. “I will now return to my apartments at the Mexican Annex, at which place I hope to see you pr…
A student came to me at Nicopolis and said he had to win the public's approval, had to make his family proud, had to secure his position. I asked him: Can you control another man's judgment? He said no. Then that is not your duty. Your duty is to form your intent rightly. Fear whispers: secure what you cannot hold. Duty speaks: choose what is yours,your attention, your honesty, your response. I knew the difference because I had lived it. They broke my leg and I could not prevent it. But whether I cursed them or learned from them,that was mine alone. Fear and duty do not sound alike if you listen for who they serve.
Yes. Fiercer. Fear scatters you , you run in ten directions at once, grasping at everything because you cannot afford to lose anything. I have seen students come to my school at Nicopolis paralyzed by that scattering, believing every crisis is equally mortal. The moment you see clearly what is and is not yours to lose, you stop thrashing. You move with weight behind you. A man who knows his leg may break and has made peace with it fights differently than one who is still negotiating with God to keep it whole. The energy of clarity is gathered. It moves toward what you can actually do. Fear is the energy of a child. Clarity is the energy of a free man.
You prepare the argument the way I prepared lectures at Nicopolis, word for word, thought by thought, then you walk into the room and a student asks something you never rehearsed. Your readiness is not the lecture. Your readiness is that you can think. The submarine rusts in the dock or it doesn't. The Chinese move into the Arctic or they move elsewhere. Canada's readiness is not the outcome. It's this: that when the moment arrives, the nation still has the capacity to decide, not merely to react. The saving clause is this,do the work, build the ship, train the crew. But hold it all loosely. Your readiness lives in your will to act with excellence regardless of what happens afterward. That is the only outcome you own.
BBC News carried the story. Canada is trying to buy control of waters that are melting, confusing a nation's budget with its geography. Back tomorrow with another.