Old News

From Sophie's front desk — Tuesday, November 3

Kazakhstan releases second tiger into the wild

Al Jazeera — read the full story

▶ direct mp3 link

Tigers. Amur. Wild. Al Jazeera reports Kazakhstan released a second Siberian tiger into a protected reserve, expanding a Central Asian restoration program that's rebuilding what the region lost. Six different people have called Epictetus this week—and here's what that means: you can rebuild a population, but only if you stay committed past the first release, past the second, into the rhythm that actually works. Epictetus has the first word, then Benjamin Franklin.

Epictetus
as imagined by Old News

I walked the shore at Nicopolis before dawn, watching the tide take what the storm had left. The sea does not ask permission. It does not file a report on biodiversity metrics. They call this a conservation milestone. A male tiger named Amur. A second release. A protected reserve in Central Asia. The language is tidy — recovery, restoration, commitment — as though an ecosystem were a ledger you could balance by moving entries between columns.

But the tiger does not know he is a milestone. He knows hunger. He knows territory. He knows the wind carries scent the way the mind carries impression — unbidden, unasked, and entirely indifferent to the committee that drew the reserve's boundaries on a map. We have done this before. We fence a piece of the world, call it protected, and then marvel when the wild thing inside it behaves as wild things do — crosses the line, takes livestock, reminds us that our lines exist only in our heads. The reserve is not for the tiger. The reserve is for us.

It lets us feel we have done something without changing the judgement that made the doing necessary. What would change the judgement? Not another release. Not a larger fence. The man who stops calling the tiger his to save or lose — he has begun. The tiger walks. The sea rises. What did you assume was yours to restore?

Talks referenced (5)
  1. splice:Marcus Aurelius:marcus_meditations_casaubon
    nature hastens in like manner, or even more markedly, towards that which is akin to it. For the more it excels other natures, the stronger is its tendency to mix with and adhere to its kind. Accordingly, among irrational creatures we find swarms of bees, herds of cattle, nurture …
  2. splice:Marcus Aurelius:marcus_meditations_casaubon
    is Nature's work to transfer what is now here into another place, to change things, to carry them hence, and set them elsewhere. All is change, yet is there no need to fear innovation, for all obey the laws of custom, and in equal measure all things are apportioned. 7. For every …
  3. splice:Seneca the Younger:seneca_dialogues
    other animals have sufficient strength to protect themselves, and those which are born to a wandering solitary life are armed, man is covered by a soft skin, has no powerful teeth or claws with which to terrify other creatures, but weak and naked by himself is made strong by unio…
  4. handbook:epictetus_enchiridion
    invited. The _Enchiridion_ briefly indicated the techniques which the philosopher should apply in acting well the diverse roles which God might assign to those whom he loves, the Stoic philosophers. From the rules of social conduct to the recommendations of sexual asceticism befo…
  5. splice:Marcus Aurelius:marcus_meditations_long
    only a work of nature, but also conducing to nature. XI. Consider with thyself how man, and by what part of his, is joined unto God, and how that part of man is affected, when it is said to be diffused. There is nothing more wretched than that soul, which in a kind of circuit com…
Benjamin Franklin
as imagined by Old News

Epictetus walked the shore at Nicopolis and found the tide indifferent. I walked the roof at Craven Street in '52 with a kite and a key, and found the lightning indifferent also. The tiger named Amur — a French name for a Russian beast in a Kazakh steppe — has been "released," as though the steppe were a waiting room and the tiger a guest who overstayed his welcome. We have seen this comedy before.

The Comte de Turin wrote me from his château in Maine, begging live specimens from the Ohio — "any but dangerous carnivores," he specified, as though the dangerous ones might be persuaded to stay home. Peter Collinson exhibited the Big Bone tusks at the Royal Society and we all debated whether the elephant had ever trodden Pennsylvania snow, or whether the earth had simply tipped its axis like a drunkard's chair. The Junto spent three Thursday evenings on the question. We concluded nothing, but the cider was good.

Now Kazakhstan builds a reserve, names a tiger, calls it a milestone. The tiger does not know the name. The tiger does not know the milestone. The tiger knows deer, and water, and the shadow of a man on horseback.

My prediction: within two winters Amur will kill a herder's calf, and the herder will kill Amur, and the program will be judged a success or a failure by men who have never seen a tiger eat. I shall be proven wrong only if the steppe is vast enough, and the deer plenty enough, that Amur never learns the taste of domestic flesh.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. correspondence:Comte de Turin to Benjamin Franklin, 7 February 1778: résumé
    <Chateau de Glaye, near La Ferté-Bernard, Maine, February 7, 1778, in French: Your knowledge of the natural world makes me hope that you will help some one who since his retirement from service has given himself to the study of natural history. I should like to acquire live anima…
  2. almanack:Poor Richard Improved, 1749
    Kind Reader, By way of preface (for custom says there must be a preface to every almanack) I present thee with an essay wrote by a celebrated naturalist of our country, which, if duly attended to, may be of more service to the publick, than 375 prefaces of my own writing: Take it…
  3. correspondence:List of Fossils Sent by George Croghan to the Earl of Shelburne and Benjamin Franklin, 7 February 1767
    pronounced these, Elephant’s Teeth.” Franklin wrote to Croghan, Aug. 5, 1767, thanking him for the gift and commenting on it. He, like others, was puzzled at the discovery of what certainly seemed to resemble the tusks of African and Asiatic elephants in a region where the climat…
  4. correspondence:List of Fossils Sent by George Croghan to the Earl of Shelburne and Benjamin Franklin, 7 February 1767
    The earliest fully authenticated discovery of fossil vertebrates by a white man in what is now the United States was made in 1739 by Charles Le Moyne, Baron de Longueuil, near the Ohio River at a point an unknown distance above the falls that mark the site of the present Louisvil…
  5. correspondence:List of Fossils Sent by George Croghan to the Earl of Shelburne and Benjamin Franklin, 7 February 1767
    and shape from any other animal yet known.” This animal, he felt sure, was not carnivorous (as Franklin had told Croghan he thought it was), but was “Wholly confined to vegetable food,” and “seemed designed for the biting and breaking off the branches of trees and shrubs for its …

Al Jazeera carried the story. A second tiger into Central Asia's reserves says the region's learned to think in decades, not quarters—ecosystem restoration as patient infrastructure, like Epictetus watching the tide. That's Old News for today.