Old News

From Sophie's front desk — Friday, October 16

'It's really hard to believe' - How Oregon primary school shooting unfolded

BBC News — read the full story

▶ direct mp3 link

You've seen this shape before: a tragedy so sudden that even the people living it can't quite accept it yet. BBC reports a shooting at Silver Rail Elementary in Bend, Oregon—three children and a teacher dead, a sixteen-year-old former student as the shooter, a teacher who fought back, an armed parent who stopped him. Epictetus has the first word on what we control and what we don't, then Alan Watts after him.

Epictetus
as imagined by Old News

I woke to this news. A school in a place called Oregon. Children. A teacher. A boy who had once sat in those rooms. The philosopher Agrippinus, when Nero's sentence reached him, was eating his lunch. He did not drop the spoon. He asked only what the sentence required of him — and went on eating. The stool does not bite. The sentence does not bite.

The arrow does not bite. It is the judgement that bites. We search for the cause. The weapon the boy carried. The boy's mind. The door that failed to lock. The parent who bore a weapon and used it. The teacher who threw himself forward. Each of these is a thing that happened. None of them is a thing we chose.

What happens next: the city will argue over laws, over doors, over screens, over prayers. They will call it senseless, and they will be right — but they will keep searching for sense in the wrong place. They will not find it there. The sense is not in the event. The sense is in the use we make of the impression. What would make me wrong: if a single parent, hearing this, turns not to the law but to the child beside them and says — this impression is not mine to own, but my action now is mine to choose. The cup is broken. The child is dead. The teacher is dead. The boy is wounded.

These are not up to us. What is up to us?

Talks referenced (5)
  1. handbook:epictetus_enchiridion
    all agreed. As when our neighbor’s boy has broken a cup, or the like, we are ready at once to say, “These are casualties that will happen”; be assured, then, that when your own cup is likewise broken, you ought to be affected just as when another’s cup was broken. Now apply this …
  2. splice:Seneca the Younger:seneca_dialogues
    peace and security? He would not have recognized the good which he had himself bestowed, and would hardly have believed, when he looked back upon himself, that so great a man could have been born in his house. Why should I go on to speak of others who would now be forgotten, if t…
  3. discourses:epictetus_discourses
    as to children masks appear terrible and fearful from inexperience, we also are affected in like manner by events (the things which happen in life) for no other reason than children are by masks. For what is a child? Ignorance. What is a child? Want of knowledge. For when a child…
  4. discourses:epictetus_discourses_carter
    as to children masks appear terrible and fearful from inexperience, we also are affected in like manner by events (the things which happen in life) for no other reason than children are by masks. For what is a child? Ignorance. What is a child? Want of knowledge. For when a child…
  5. handbook:epictetus_enchiridion
    considered to be the lasting message of the teacher. In contrast to Seneca and Marcus Aurelius, Epictetus had no subjective approach to the Stoic doctrines. Moral philosophy was the center of his teaching, and epistemology was only instrumental. It is even permissible to say that…
Alan Watts
as imagined by Old News

Epictetus, you draw the line too clean. The cup is broken, yes — but the hand that held it, the clay it came from, the thirst that reached for it: where exactly does "not up to us" end and "up to us" begin? I watched a teacher in Oregon fight a boy who had once sat at her desk, and an armed parent step from the ordinary world into fire.

Neither of them paused to sort the ledger. The universe does not ask permission to move through us. We build these fortresses of "control" and "acceptance" because the alternative — feeling the world break in real time, feeling the child's finger almost touch yours and not knowing whether it wants to be touched — that alternative terrifies the ego that calls itself "I." The Zen master destroys the student's foundation not to leave rubble but to show the ground was never separate from the fall.

I drank for years to forget the groundlessness. The bottle was a stern teacher: it stripped every prop until the only thing left was the falling itself. There is no "up to us." There is only this.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. lecture:Individual and the World
    of a teacher who knows just exactly what’s going on. The teacher himself has been through it. And he’s not like the other kind of teacher who is still a student and who is urging his students to keep on the rat race because he’s still on it. Finally, it dawns. You see, when you w…
  2. lecture:Bushido
    ‘Ah,’ said the Roshi, ‘You had me there.’ Another story that’s like it is the teacher was entertaining four students to tea, three students giving them tea. He pulled his fan out and tossed it to the first student and said ‘What is it?’ he said it’s a fact. You have it to the nex…
  3. book:in my own way
    changed their lives about, rearranged their marriages, and altered their vocations. The school board got wind of the fact that something most peculiar was happening under their auspices, and sent an investigator to one of his classes. He found the students sitting on the floor, i…
  4. lecture:Individual and the World
    therefore, for us, brought up in that way, it’s a very dangerous thing to trust yourself to rashly. And therefore, to learn how to do it, we have to learn in protected circumstances. So the Zen school provides protected circumstances in which we can behave in unexpected ways, or …
  5. lecture:Journey to India
    of his students is clinging. What is the foundation of sanity? What do you base your life on? And when he has found out what that is for each student, he destroys it. He shows you that you can’t found a way of life on that. That it leads you into all sorts of inconsistencies and …

The story ran in BBC News. A teacher fought back, and an armed parent from the community stopped the shooter—the intervention itself now part of what the school must reckon with. That's Old News for today.