Old News

From Sophie's front desk — Saturday, October 31

G20 'family photo' cancelled after protests over presence of Russian minister

BBC News — read the full story

▶ direct mp3 link

The family photo never happened. Ed Miliband confronted Russia's foreign minister on the G20 floor, accused him of killing civilians in Ukraine, and the ceremonial moment—the one symbolic gesture that brings all twenty economies together for the cameras—was cancelled. BBC reports the fracture as unprecedented: the multilateral institution itself breaking live, not behind closed doors. Hypatia has the first word on what it means when the forum dies. Then Watts.

Hypatia of Alexandria
as imagined by Old News

You stood beside me when the Serapeum fell — not the stones only, the scrolls, the armillary spheres Theon had calibrated, the very place where a student could lay a proof against the night sky and watch it hold. The mob did not ask permission. They brought fire and the patriarch's blessing and called it purification. We lost the building. We did not lose the method. Now I hear of your G20.

A photograph cancelled because two ministers could not stand in the same frame without one naming what the other has done. No fire. No stones thrown. Only the refusal to perform the gesture that says we still share a table. The family photo — your word — assumes a kinship that the war has already disproved. The cancellation is not the fracture.

It is the admission that the fracture existed before the camera clicked. In Alexandria we taught that a diagram does not become true because the geometers agree to sign it. It becomes true because the necessary consequence follows from the axioms. Your diplomats have been signing the photograph for years while the axioms — sovereignty, territory, the prohibition on annexation — were being broken in the open. The photograph was the mirror. The confrontation broke it.

The question is not whether the mirror can be remade. The question is whether any mirror can show a face that has already turned away.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. hypatia:plotinus_v2
    issue,[70] that matter is the (eternal) location, and place (of all generation).[71] MATTER AS LOCATION OF FORMS REMAINS IMPASSIBLE. When Plato, rightfully, calls matter "the location of forms," he is not thereby attributing any passion to matter; he only indicates that matters g…
  2. hypatia:plotinus_v2
    the images. Consequently as they will be hindered in a direct ratio to the existence of a medium, this opinion does not run counter to our own hypothesis (that there is no medium). A COSMOLOGICAL MEDIUM IS NECESSARY, BUT IT AFFECTS SIGHT ONLY ACCIDENTALLY. Those who (with Plotino…
  3. hypatia:plotinus_v4
    in generation. NECESSITY OF INTERNECINE WARFARE. What then (will it be objected) is the necessity of this natural internecine warfare of animals, and also of men? First, animals have to devour each other in order to renew themselves; they could not, indeed, last eternally, even i…
  4. hypatia:plotinus_v4
    accomplish something, which before was forbidden. Besides, it is an error not to trace to a single principle the government of the universe, attributing everything to the stars, as if there were not a single Chief from which depends the universe, and who distributes to every bein…
  5. hypatia:plotinus_v3
    INTELLIGENCE CONTAINS ALL THINGS THAT ARE CONFORMED TO THE GOOD. 16. Instead of stopping at this multiple beauty, it must be abandoned to rise (to the Good), the supreme principle. By reasoning not according to the nature of our world, but according to that of the universal Intel…
Alan Watts
as imagined by Old News

Hypatia saw the mirror break in Alexandria, and now the G20 cancels its family portrait because the uncle who bombs hospitals refuses to leave the frame.

The ritual dissolves when the fiction of accord costs more than the quarrel itself, and no staging recovers trust spent on abstractions.

The next gathering yields either a smaller picture or an empty chair, unless the players remember that the game requires both sides to keep playing.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. book:book the
    the conflict: to call each other the worst names, but to refrain from dropping bombs. Or, if they insist that there must be some fighting to keep armies in trim, they restrict it to local conflicts in “unimportant” countries. Voltaire should have said that if the Devil did not ex…
  2. book:early writings of alan watts ed. snelling
    to debate. Finally, to return to that last controversial paragraph: when ‘‘Buddhism in the Modern World’”’ was eventually re- released in pamphlet form, that offending item had been duly deleted, a fact welcomed by A. C. March when he reviewed the publication in Buddhism in Engla…
  3. lecture:World as Play
    again at the end. You shake hands before boxing. You do these various things, you bow before judo contests and so on. And that means that you recognize the opponent. As an honorable opponent. Somebody with whom a fight is a really important matter. And that is really one of the m…
  4. lecture:Four Ways to the Center
    aware of that conflict going on, because conscious attention doesn’t need to ordinarily to focus upon it. And so you don’t get involved and you’re not anxious about what party is winning and what party is losing that keeping up a kind of balance. Now then, to take this a step fur…
  5. lecture:Veil of Thoughts
    matters about which we fight with each other are increasingly abstract, and the wars fought about abstract problems get worse and worse. We are thinking about vast abstractions, ideologies called communism, capitalism—all these systems—and paying less and less attention to the wo…

The story ran in BBC News. A G20 family photo was cancelled after Britain's foreign secretary confronted Russia over Ukraine, a small fracture in what's meant to be a club of consensus. That's Old News for today.