Old News

From Sophie's front desk — Wednesday, October 7

Trump to speak to Putin about plague lab worker's death in Russia

BBC News — read the full story

▶ direct mp3 link

What happens when a plague death in Russia becomes a diplomatic incident, and nobody can agree on whether it happened at all? B.B.C.'s reporting a lab worker dead — possibly pneumonic plague — and Trump's planning to take it straight to Putin, while Moscow denies the whole thing and W.H.O.'s demanding answers nobody's giving. The real question isn't the death itself; it's whether we can trust what we're told about what kills us, especially when the lab is locked behind a border. Thoreau thought hard about the difference between silence and secrecy. Watts will meet him there.

Henry David Thoreau
as imagined by Old News

I watched the graphite in my father's kiln refuse to be hurried. You heat it wrong and the structure collapses into dust , no treaty, no telegram, no declaration from a capital can coax the carbon back into order. The plague does not read the communiqués. It does not pause for the conversation between the two men who claim the world between them. It moves in the blood the way water moves in the spring thaw: by a law older than any bureau, indifferent to the name on the door.

A worker dies in a building where men keep what should not be kept. The government says it did not happen. The other government demands a conversation. The world body asks for the record. Meanwhile the thing itself — whatever it is — has already gone where breath carries it.

I have seen the ice go out on Walden in a single afternoon after weeks of seeming solidity. The crack starts where no one is watching. The news arrives days later in the village, and by then the river is already running. We build laboratories the way we build railroads: to master distance and time. We forget that the materials have their own patience.

The pencil in my hand remembers the forest it came from. The disease remembers the soil.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. thoreau:walden
    he holds up his head and asks, “What’s the news?” as if the rest of mankind had stood his sentinels. Some give directions to be waked every half hour, doubtless for no other purpose; and then, to pay for it, they tell what they have dreamed. After a night’s sleep the news is as i…
  2. thoreau:a_week
    where the waters annually deposit their slime, not where they reach in some freshet only. A man is not his hope, nor his despair, nor yet his past deed. We know not yet what we have done, still less what we are doing. Wait till evening, and other parts of our day’s work will shin…
  3. thoreau:walden
    as I hear, the other day at one of the offices to learn the foreign news by the last arrival, that several large squares of plate glass belonging to the establishment were broken by the pressure,—news which I seriously think a ready wit might write a twelve-month, or twelve years…
  4. thoreau:walden
    to support you, if they be necessary; and pile the empty cans sky-high for a sign. Were preserved meats invented to preserve meat merely? Nay, be a Columbus to whole new continents and worlds within you, opening new channels, not of trade, but of thought. Every man is the lord of…
  5. thoreau:walden
    a new leaf at last? This phenomenon is more exhilarating to me than the luxuriance and fertility of vineyards. True, it is somewhat excrementitious in its character, and there is no end to the heaps of liver lights and bowels, as if the globe were turned wrong side outward; but t…
Ask Henry David Thoreau more →
You watched your father's kiln refuse hurry — what did the graphite teach you about power?

The graphite in my father's Concord kiln taught me that power... which ignores the grain of things becomes ash. You cannot command carbon to crystallize on your schedule any more than you can command the pickerel in Walden to bite because the legislature declared fishing season open. The pencil leads we baked emerged whole only when the heat rose at the pace the ore dictated , not the pace the contract demanded. Men who mistake leverage for law always find the structure crumbling in their hands. The ice on Walden goes out when the water decides, not when the selectmen vote. Power that does not serve the material's own patience is not power at all , it is merely violence waiting to be repaid.

"The crack starts where no one is watching" — have you ever seen a truth break that way?

I stood on the shore of Walden in March of 1847 and watched a sheet of ice that had held a team of oxen three days prior fracture in a single hour. No wind, no shout, no visible cause , only the sun's angle shifting a degree and the water beneath remembering its nature. The crack ran the length of the pond before anyone in the village knew it had started. By the time the surveyor arrived with his chain, the black water was already lapping the edges. Truth does not wait for the witness. It breaks where the pressure has been building longest, in the dark, under the weight everyone agreed to ignore. The pencil in my hand still carries the graphite my father and I coaxed from the kiln that would not be hurried.

The pencil remembers the forest; the disease remembers the soil — what does the railroad forget?

The Fitchburg line forgets the men who laid its ties , Irish hands blistered by the adze, paid a dollar a day to blast ledge where the bobolink nested. It forgets the white oak and chestnut felled for sleepers, each tree a century of growing sacrificed so a merchant reaches Boston by noon instead of sundown. It forgets that the meadow still floods in April regardless of the embankment, that the muskrat does not read the timetable, that my bean rows yielded twelve bushels to the acre while the train shook the rails fifty feet away. The railroad forgets that arrival is not the same as being there. The telegraph wire humming beside it carries the price of cotton... but not the weight of the soil that grew it.

or ask your own question (opens email)…
Alan Watts
as imagined by Old News

Thoreau watched graphite in his father's kiln and saw... the truth of it , heat it wrong and the structure collapses, no treaty can coax carbon back to order. He's right, the plague reads no telegrams. But Thoreau stops at the forest's patience. He forgets the comedy.

We know the virus has no passport, no ideology, no respect for the red telephone between capitals. We've always known. And still we build our high-containment cathedrals, staff them with priests in negative-pressure vestments, and then perform astonishment when the ritual leaks. The disease remembers the soil, yes , but we remember the disease into a crisis, a bargaining chip, a reason for the American president to ring the Russian premier as... though diplomacy could negotiate with a bacterium.

You see the farce: the carbon pretending it can bargain with the heat. The pencil does remember the forest... But the hand holding the pencil? It keeps forgetting it's made of the same dust. So why do we keep staging this theater of control when the audience — the soil, the air, the bug itself — never bought tickets?

Talks referenced (5)
  1. book:collected letters ed. j. watts
    offered. The president is a Dr. Baker (woman), who is not a psychologist but a research worker in a most fascinating branch — tissue culture, which apparently means keeping dead things alive. She is the assistant of Dr. Alexis Carrel, who works with Col. Lindbergh on strange scie…
  2. book:collected letters ed. j. watts
    answer to hers regarding his topic for an upcoming lecture at the Washington School of Psychiatry that October. He had given the title of the lecture as “Controlling Consciousness,” and Margaret was hoping that Alan wasn’t going to “lecture on the use of LSD and related substance…
  3. book:collected letters ed. j. watts
    press, we learned of Richard’s death. He is the first of Alan’s progeny to pass on. May he rest in peace. CONTENTS i 7 Illustrations Foreword by Joan Watts Preface by Anne Watts Part I. Early Letters: 1928-37 Part II. Coming to America: 1938-41 Part III. On Becoming a Priest — Th…
  4. book:way of liberation the
    the blood ; it is some kind of a bug and it comes out in itchy spots all over the body. But you do not want to cut off the spots; what you have to do is kill the bug. So you kill the bug. Well, then you find you have real problems because you have to introduce other bugs to kill …
  5. book:collected letters ed. j. watts
    yours, Alan Watts SOCIETY FOR COMPARATIVE PHILOSOPHY | SAUSALITO, CALIFORNIA | APRIL 29, 1966 Mr. Pearce Young | Chairman, Assembly Criminal Procedures Committee | Sacramento, California Dear Mr. Young: Your committee is very much to be commended for resisting the pressures for “…
Ask Alan Watts more →
What comedy does Thoreau miss in the forest's patience?

Thoreau kneels at the pond and watches the ants wage their Trojan War, and he records it with the gravity of Homer... but he never laughs at the generals... which is to say he never laughs at himself. I walked those same woods in '47 with a tape recorder and a hangover, and the chickadees didn't care about my metaphysics any more than they cared about his pencils. The comedy isn't in the forest's patience; it's in the naturalist's insistence that patience is a virtue rather than a vegetable.

Why cast scientists as priests in negative-pressure vestments?

The priest and the physician were once the same man in the ancient temple, and the negative-pressure suit is only the modern chasuble. I watched the virologists at Fort Detrick move through their airlocks with the same deliberate grace I saw in Anglican canons at Chichester, both tribes trusting the liturgy of protocol to hold back what the liturgy itself cannot name. The bacterium does not read the protocol, and the carbon does not bargain with the heat.

How does the hand forget it's dust like the pencil?

The hand forgets because consciousness, that clever mirror, reflects only the surface and calls it depth, mistaking the reflection for the face. I watched this in my own seminary days at Seabury-Western , the more theology I learned, the further I drifted from the dust I was made of, mistaking the map for the territory and the word for the wind. The ego is not a thing but a cramp, the fist clenched around water it insists is solid, and the unbending finger points everywhere... but at itself, never noticing the hand is made of what it tries to hold.

or ask your own question (opens email)…

The story ran in B.B.C. News. A Russian lab worker's death from suspected pneumonic plague is prompting Trump to engage Putin directly, while Moscow denies the reports and the W.H.O. calls for transparency — a reminder that biosafety failures aren't theoretical problems, they're diplomatic ones. That's all for today.