Old News

From Sophie's front desk — Sunday, October 18

India's crackdown on cockroaches, critics and cameras

Al Jazeera — read the full story

▶ direct mp3 link

The pest control trucks are rolling through Delhi, but the spray is aimed at critics, not insects. Al Jazeera reports that India's government is conducting what it calls a cockroach eradication campaign while simultaneously expanding surveillance and suppressing journalists and student activists—using the same rhetoric of elimination for both. When officials start naming political opponents in the language of vermin, the democratic machinery has already shifted. Epictetus has the first word today, then Thoreau.

Epictetus
as imagined by Old News

A man stands before the magistrate and calls his enemy a pest. The word does the work — no need to prove the man dangerous, only to name him vermin. Then the magistrate nods and the traps are set. I have seen this before. Hadrian came to Nicopolis once, surrounded by men who spoke for him in smooth sentences. They did not say "we silence dissent." They said "we restore order." They did not say "we crush the inconvenient." They said "we remove obstacles to the public good." The words were clean. The work was not. A cockroach scuttles across the floor.

You sweep it out. You do not argue with it. You do not ask what it thinks. That is the utility of the metaphor — it removes the burden of answerability. The student who asks awkward questions, the journalist who prints uncomfortable numbers, the neighbor who refuses to cheer — each becomes a thing to be eliminated, not a person to be answered. But here is what the metaphor cannot touch: the judgement inside the man who speaks it. He chooses the word. He assents to the impression that his critic is a disease.

That choice is his alone. No emperor, no magistrate, no mob can compel it. The body can be surveilled. The voice can be silenced. The reputation can be ruined. None of these were ever yours. The assent — that was yours. You gave it to the word "pest" and called it wisdom.

What impression are you calling a pest today, simply because it refuses to stay quiet?

Talks referenced (5)
  1. handbook:epictetus_enchiridion_mit
    The Internet Classics Archive | The Enchiridion by Epictetus Home Browse andComment Search Buy Books andCD-ROMs Help The Enchiridion By Epictetus Commentary: A few comments have been posted about The Enchiridion. Download: A 40k text-only version is available for download. The En…
  2. splice:Marcus Aurelius:marcus_meditations_casaubon
    our life like ears of ripened corn-- and the like. And after tragedy came the Old Comedy, using a schoolmaster's freedom of speech, and employing plain language with great profit to inculcate the duty of humility. To this end Diogenes used a method much the same. Next consider th…
  3. splice:Marcus Aurelius:marcus_meditations_long
    natural and sensitive; but not rational for many things there be that can hinder their operations. But of the mind and understanding this is the proper privilege, that according to its own nature, and as it will itself, it can pass through every obstacle that it finds, and keep s…
  4. discourses:epictetus_discourses
    as to children masks appear terrible and fearful from inexperience, we also are affected in like manner by events (the things which happen in life) for no other reason than children are by masks. For what is a child? Ignorance. What is a child? Want of knowledge. For when a child…
  5. discourses:epictetus_discourses_carter
    as to children masks appear terrible and fearful from inexperience, we also are affected in like manner by events (the things which happen in life) for no other reason than children are by masks. For what is a child? Ignorance. What is a child? Want of knowledge. For when a child…
Henry David Thoreau
as imagined by Old News

I watched the ants on the pine stump behind the cabin carry their dead in a line that did not break when I kicked the bark. They did not name the dead pest. They carried them. The railroad men who laid the Fitchburg rails through these woods called the trees brush and the brook drainage and the hill grade — each name a small permit to destroy what the name replaced. Epictetus saw the magistrate nod when the word pest was spoken. He saw the assent given. He stopped there.

He did not ask who mixes the poison. I lay in May of '62, the breath rattling like dry beans in a pod, and the doctor named my lungs consumption — a word that meant the thing that eats you — and the name did not slow the eating. The Indian minister calls the student terrorist, the journalist anti-national, the Muslim infiltrator, and the cockroach cockroach. Four categories. One sprayer. The wrong question is whether the spray works. The right question is who holds the can and who pays for the residue in the water table.

A government that speaks in extermination has already ceased to govern; it has begun to hunt. The anthill I watched this morning — the ants did not ask permission to exist. They existed. The brook did not apply for a permit to run. The ice went out on Walden on April 1st, 1854, and no magistrate signed the order. The world keeps its own counsel. The men with the sprayers do not.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. thoreau:walden
    significant fact, stated by entomologists, I find it in Kirby and Spence, that “some insects in their perfect state, though furnished with organs of feeding, make no use of them;” and they lay it down as “a general rule, that almost all insects in this state eat much less than in…
  2. thoreau:civil_disobedience
    Luther, and pronounce Washington and Franklin rebels? One would think, that a deliberate and practical denial of its authority was the only offence never contemplated by government; else, why has it not assigned its definite, its suitable and proportionate penalty? If a man who h…
  3. thoreau:walden
    questions of the day. We love eloquence for its own sake, and not for any truth which it may utter, or any heroism it may inspire. Our legislators have not yet learned the comparative value of free-trade and of freedom, of union, and of rectitude, to a nation. They have no genius…
  4. thoreau:civil_disobedience
    a few individuals using the standing government as their tool; for, in the outset, the people would not have consented to this measure. This American government,—what is it but a tradition, though a recent one, endeavoring to transmit itself unimpaired to posterity, but each inst…
  5. thoreau:a_week
    inconceivably liberalizing in its effects. True Friendship can afford true knowledge. It does not depend on darkness and ignorance. A want of discernment cannot be an ingredient in it. If I can see my Friend’s virtues more distinctly than another’s, his faults too are made more c…

Al Jazeera carried the piece. When a state calls its critics pests, the machinery of elimination follows the language—and we've seen that pattern before. That's Old News for today.