Old News

From Sophie's front desk — Thursday, October 1

New York Governor appoints special prosecutor to Cornell frat rape case

NYT — read the full story

▶ direct mp3 link

The chairs in Chi Phi's house are still warm, but nobody's sitting. New York's Governor has named Attorney General Letitia James as special prosecutor to the Cornell frat rape investigation — a move that amounts to saying the people already handling it failed. Students demanded action; the state heard them; now the machinery shifts. Marcus Aurelius holds the first word, then Benjamin Franklin.

Marcus Aurelius
as imagined by Old News

A governor sends his attorney general to a university town because the local magistrates would not move. The story calls it accountability. It is not. It is the center admitting the periphery has rotted, and sending a cleaner instead of a cure. You saw this, Marcus. At Carnuntum, a tribune's son raped a camp-follower. The legion's court dismissed it — "no witnesses, no crime." You did not send a special prosecutor. You rode there yourself. The tribune was cashiered before sundown.

The court clerk who buried the complaint was flogged. The signal traveled faster than any edict: the law protects the powerful only until the sovereign looks. Cornell's students know this. They occupied the quad. They named the fraternity. They forced the governor's hand. The appointment is not justice — it is the price of the protest. Letitia James will pursue the case. She may win convictions.

But the machine that buried it — the deans, the campus police, the alumni donors who whisper to trustees — that machine remains. It will bury the next one more quietly. You were adopted at seventeen by a man who had never failed to look. Antoninus taught you: the office does not clean itself. The man in the office cleans it, or he does not. The governor has not cleaned his own prosecutors. He has borrowed another's sword. You will find, Marcus, that a borrowed sword cuts both ways. When the next case comes, the governor will still have no magistrate he trusts.

Keep your own eyes on the court clerk. That is where the rot lives.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. splice:Epictetus:epictetus_discourses
    how? And if by chance this public instructor shall be detected, this pædagogue, what kind of things will he be compelled to suffer? when then a man fears these things, is it possible for him to be bold with his whole soul to superintend men? It cannot be: it is impossible. In the…
  2. splice:Epictetus:epictetus_discourses_carter
    how? And if by chance this public instructor shall be detected, this pædagogue, what kind of things will he be compelled to suffer? when then a man fears these things, is it possible for him to be bold with his whole soul to superintend men? It cannot be: it is impossible. In the…
  3. splice:Seneca the Younger:seneca_dialogues
    what the law may be among you Stoic philosophers in such a case. I suppose that you keep the action which I bring against another distinct from that which he Strings against me, and the two processes are not merged into one? For instance, if a man entrusts me with money, and afte…
  4. splice:Seneca the Younger:seneca_dialogues
    men," our opponent argues, "will be ungrateful, if no legal remedy exists against ingratitude." Nay, fewer, because then benefits will be bestowed with more discrimination, In the next place, it is not advisable that it should be publicly known how many ungrateful men there are: …
  5. meditations:marcus_meditations_casaubon
    the reason of justice. 2. You will think little of a pleasing song, a dance, or a gymnastic display, if you analyse the melody into its separate notes, and ask yourself regarding each, "Does this impress me?" You will blush to own it; and so also if you analyse the dance into its…
Benjamin Franklin
as imagined by Old News

Marcus Aurelius calls it a borrowed sword. He is not wrong — the governor in Albany sends his attorney general to Ithaca because the local magistrates would not move, and the center admits the periphery has rotted. I grant the diagnosis. But I also remember the Junto, twenty-seven years a-building in a rented room above a print shop. No governor sent us a cleaner. We twelve leather-apron men — a glazier, a surveyor, a cabinetmaker, a scrivener — met each Friday to read, dispute, and mend our own corner.

From that periphery grew the Library Company, the Union Fire Company, the Philosophical Society, the Academy. The center noticed us only after the work was done. A special prosecutor is a fine instrument when the local machinery has seized. Yet the machinery seizes because the citizens who ought to oil it have gone home. Students in the quad demand reform; they might also demand a grand jury of their own neighbors, a constable chosen by the ward, a coroner who answers to the township and not the capital. The Romans called it municipium — the burden and the privilege of governing one's own street.

Send the attorney general. She will cut clean. But the next case will find the same magistrates, the same silence, the same borrowed sword. A periphery that waits for the center's cure has already surrendered its franchise. The fire company does not wait for the governor's bucket brigade. It keeps its leather buckets by the door.

Talks referenced (5)
  1. correspondence:A Defense of Conduct, 15 February 1738
    only an unfortunate accident, but the grand jury, receiving evidence that Jones had thrown the spirits willfully, indicted him, Remington, and Tackerbury for murder. Andrew Bradford used the opportunity to attack the Masons: on August 4 the American Weekly Mercury printed an unfr…
  2. correspondence:Pennsylvania Assembly: Reply to the Governor, 20 January 1764
    everything in revenge.” Reports of a proposed march on the city increased, and after the events at Conestoga and Lancaster were known in Philadelphia it became clear that the major objective of such a march would be the killing of the Indians on Province Island. It seemed desirab…
  3. correspondence:The Petition to the House of Lords against the Boston Port Bill, [26 March 1774]: résumé
    proceedings are repugnant to every principle of law and justice, and threaten every man’s security. To condemn unheard is to remove all defense against false accusation, all protection of the innocent. In the colonies the law provides redress for injuries sustained there and, as …
  4. correspondence:Proposal for a Prussian-American Treaty of Amity and Commerce: Articles 13, 23, and 24, [before 10 November 1784]
    accused of not being “peaceably” employed); he incorporated this change into his first draft of the proposal, which he submitted to Franklin and Adams for review. By the time the commissioners settled on a final draft, the article included women, children, and “scholars of every …
  5. correspondence:Thomas Hutchinson to ——, 4 October 1768
    In this state of things there was no security but quitting my posts, which nothing but the last extremity would justify. As chief justice for two years after our first disorders I kept the grand juries tollerably well to their duty. The last spring there had been several riots, a…

The story ran in the New York Times. When a governor loses faith in the magistrates he appointed, he sends someone else—which either means the first set was asleep or the second is there to do what shouldn't have to be done. That's the close on this one.