From Sophie's front desk — Saturday, November 14
AFP — read the full story
Watch the Slideo →You are about to hear roughly 93,000 delegates at COP31 in Antalya argue over when the next IPCC climate report should land. AFP reports that the EU's Diana Acconcia wants the seventh assessment out before the 2028 stocktake, while Saudi Arabia, China and India want it pushed to 2029. Acconcia also accused some parties of undermining the science because they do not want to act. Hypatia of Alexandria takes the first pass at the timing dispute, then Benjamin Franklin takes the practical stakes.
The Pharos keeps its beam on its own terms. It burns, and the sea receives the geometry of its light, or founders. I mean this literally. It is what the lighthouse is. In Alexandria we knew that timetables are kept by the body, and the mind only follows them. The Serapeum fell because men decided the calendar of truth could be accelerated by fire.
The mob's haste played no part in the speed of the fire. They burned at the rate papyrus burns. A demonstration reaches what is necessary; a count of voices reaches only what is probable. Now I hear that nine hundred thousand voices gather to decide when the heavens' testimony may be spoken. Nine hundred thousand. The Mouseion held perhaps a few hundred at its height, and we still could not protect the arithmetic from the bishop's decree.
The stars keep to their courses whatever a consul demands. They hold to their schedule even while a merchant frets over the harvest. Their influence — if that word still carries its weight — consists in their contemplation of the intelligible. They are the timetable. What I never settled: whether the soul that has seen the necessary can endure watching the probable pretend to govern it. The mob that dragged me from my chariot argued only with its hands.
issue,[70] that matter is the (eternal) location, and place (of all generation).[71] MATTER AS LOCATION OF FORMS REMAINS IMPASSIBLE. When Plato, rightfully, calls matter "the location of forms," he is not thereby attributing any passion to matter; he only indicates that matters g…
BE ATTRIBUTED TO THE STARS' BODY OR WILL. 35. How then do these powers exert themselves?--for we have to retrace our steps to give a clear explanation. What difference is exhibited by the comparison of one triangle with another? What action does the one exert on another, how is i…
or riddled with holes. To this it may be objected that nature may have endowed our body with a disposition to permit perspiration to issue easily. To this (the Stoics) answer that certain substances (like ivory[62]), which when worked into thin sheets, admit, in all their parts, …
similar relations.[430] On the whole, therefore, the Plotinic authorship is much more strongly indicated than the Numenian. The next treatment of matter in the Fourth Ennead, is semi-stoical.[431] The opposite aspects of the Universe appear again as "phronesis" and "phusis." We f…
be deduced therefrom. THIRD ENNEAD, BOOK EIGHT. Of Nature, Contemplation and Unity.[177] (_These three subjects are discussed in paragraphs 1-4, 5-7, and 8-16. The plain paragraph numbers are those of the Teubner edition; those in parenthesis are the Creuzer (Didot) edition._) A.…
Hypatia of Alexandria spoke of the Pharos as a light that kept to its own schedule and bent for no one. I printed twenty-six years of Poor Richard, each edition promising the farmer his planting dates, the mariner his tides, the housewife her seasons. We printed the timetable because the seasons would not wait for our convenience. The moon does not delay its phase because a committee in Antalya has not reached consensus. Ninety-three thousand delegates.
The number staggers. In Paris we managed with three commissioners and a handful of secretaries, and even then the comte de Vergennes made us wait three weeks while Madrid made up its mind. But we were negotiating a peace the armies had already won. These delegates negotiate with the atmosphere itself, which has no ministry, no envoy, and no patience for a deadline slid from twenty-eight to twenty-nine. Some of them ask for more time to prepare the report.
I know that request. It is the request of a man who owes a debt and hopes the creditor will die before the note comes due. The science is not a crop that ripens on a later schedule because the planter finds the harvest inconvenient. It is the lightning stroke: it arrives when the cloud is ready, and the rod had better be in place beforehand. I published "Early to bed and early to rise" because the print shop demanded it, and I did not love the dawn.
The atmosphere makes no such accommodation.
The commissioners of the Faculté de médecine and the Académie des sciences—with the exception of Franklin—met in Paris on Wednesday, August 11, to sign the report of their four-month investigation. Franklin, unable to travel, had signed in advance, having received the pristine ma…
the form of a query when submitting their proposed articles on June 29. Articles 15, 16, and 17: The American commissioners’ June 29 revisions to four of the articles (2, 3, 4, and 5) that Hartley proposed to them on June 19. Article 18: Excerpted from the American commissioners’…
<The Hague, June 27[–30], in French: I have written the Grand Pensionary that the treaty has arrived, and the Grand Facteur has approved my letter. June 28: The Grand Pensionary has set our interview for tomorrow morning. Last night came your packet of the 22nd, which I devoured …
The initial negotiations for a commercial treaty between the United States and Portugal, conducted between Franklin and the conde de Sousa Coutinho, took place without the knowledge of the other American commissioners and have left no written trace. Whether Sousa Coutinho had pre…
This meeting, in Deane’s quarters in Paris at six in the evening of January 8, was the commissioners’ reward for all the frustrations of the previous year. Vergennes had announced to them on December 12 that France was ready to negotiate, but three weeks of silence followed while…
The story ran in AFP. Science that arrives after the decision it was meant to inform is just history with better footnotes. That's Old News for today, and I'll be back tomorrow with another. The full episode is at ekrasworks.com/oldnews.